Yosemite Black Bears Prefer Minivans

A study published in the October 2009 issue of Journal of Mammalogy found that black bears in Yosemite National Park selectively foraged for a particular type of vehicle: breaking into minivans more often than any other vehicle, based on vehicle availability.


(National Forest Service image)

The Abstract states: “Black bears forage selectively to balance energetic and nutritional gains with foraging costs. Selection of minivans by bears in Yosemite National Park was the likely consequence of efforts to maximize caloric gain and minimize costs by targeting vehicles with higher probabilities of payoff.”

There are several, non-mutually exclusive possibilities for the higher rate of minvan break-ins:

  • Minivans may emit stronger food odors, regardless of how much food is present inside. (Blame the sticky car seats and small children who spill food and drink.)
  • Minivan passengers may leave more food inside their vehicles. (Most vehicles broken into have some amount of food or trash inside. Yosemite visitors are required to use bear lockers or other approved storage methods.)
  • Minivans may be physically easier to break into.
  • A few individual bears may have learned to repeatedly break into minivans for a better payoff.

Station wagons were broken into the least (see chart below).

 

Chart: Percentage of vehicles broken into by black bears (Ursus americanus; used—black) and parked overnight (available—gray) by class of vehicle in 2004–2005. Only use of minivans surpassed availability and shows that black bears strongly selected for this class of vehicle.

 

The study, Selective Foraging For Anthropogenic Resources By Black Bears: Minivans In Yosemite National Park, is available online.

Modesto Bee article: “Yosemite bears know big picnics come in minivans”

More Articles | Comments (6) | Save & Share
Filed under: Environment, Places

Comments

hikerjab
Full Member
Joined: 9/1/09
Posts: 26
October 27, 2009 at 3:25 p.m. (EDT)

And my wife wanted a minivan....

Alicia
Editor in Chief
Joined: 3/14/01
Posts: 1273
October 27, 2009 at 3:33 p.m. (EDT)

Hey, I hadn't considered that before, but if you don't like minivans you can use this as an excuse to not get one.

I personally felt awash with good sense for having a station wagon, the least likely to be broken into (j/k).

Explorer Robby
Senior Member
Joined: 4/20/08
Posts: 101
October 27, 2009 at 4:31 p.m. (EDT)

Strange, I would have thought the same kid-making-mess-with-food standard would apply to a station wagon as well as the easier to break into (more, larger windows). Guess those with station wagons are closer to the floor with less foot room and tend to keep it cleaner than the mini-van folks.

tommangan
Assistant Editor
Joined: 4/12/08
Posts: 72
October 28, 2009 at 9:38 a.m. (EDT)

The same engineering that makes it easy for soccer moms to get into and out of a minivan probably is what makes them easier for bears to get into and out of.

I noticed sports cars had a very low break-in rate. I think I'll mention that to my wife next time when we trade in.

Alicia
Editor in Chief
Joined: 3/14/01
Posts: 1273
October 28, 2009 at 1:46 p.m. (EDT)

Explorer Robby said:

Guess those with station wagons are closer to the floor with less foot room and tend to keep it cleaner than the mini-van folks.

I think there may be fewer black hole spaces to lose food inside a station wagon, or at least in my Subaru Outback. Or maybe we're just obsessively neat rule-followers, and the bears know it (still kidding).

Now sports cars I would expect to be the cleanest.

Explorer Robby
Senior Member
Joined: 4/20/08
Posts: 101
October 30, 2009 at 8:34 a.m. (EDT)

Heck, my pickup truck is mostly clean. Granted, there is dirt from my feet on the floor mats, but I dont eat or anything in it, I always remove clutter from it and its a work truck. I blame the kids here. Minivans always mean kids, kids always mean mess. (I have 4 of them, I should know).

Share Your Thoughts

You must be a registered member to comment.

New users: click to become a member

Returning members: click here to log in