If the Shoe Fits: A Buyers' Guide to Trail Running Shoes

Choosing the right trail running shoes, or trail runners, is critical for a positive running experience. Trail runners are about function, not fashion. So, before you punch in your credit card number on your favorite outdoor retailer’s website, or randomly choose a shoe off the wall at your local sporting goods store, consider the features of the various trail running shoes on the market, as well as the unique nature and biomechanics of your feet.

 

Know Your Feet

Like feet, trail runners come in all shapes, sizes, and stability levels.

First, take a look at your feet. Are they wide or narrow? Are your arches high or flat? (See foot types below.) Do you run or walk on the outsides or insides of your feet? There is a continuum of running shoes, from the neutral cushioning category, to the moderate stability category, to the high stability category.


Trail runners come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and stability levels.

Stability, aka arch support, is the amount of rigidity in a shoe and is one of the most important considerations in selecting a running shoe. Knee pain, shin splints, and plantar fasciitis oftentimes signal a need for more stability. Conversely, shoes with too much stability can force a runner to the outsides of their feet, causing ankle pain.

If you have a running store nearby, a knowledgeable staff member will be able to examine your feet and watch you walk and run. By checking your gait, it becomes apparent whether you over-pronate, supinate/under-pronate, or neither, thus directing you to a shoe with the proper amount of stability.

Over-pronation means rolling your foot inward while walking or running. It occurs when the heel strikes first and then rolls overly inwards to toe-off. This can create torque on the lower leg with each foot strike. Some slight pronation is normal.

In general, the flatter the foot, the more likely a person is to over-pronate. Flat feet are more flexible, thus requiring a shoe that can control that inwards motion of the foot. Added stability in a shoe helps to support the arch and guide the foot in a straightforward motion. If the over-pronation is minimal, a “moderate stability” shoe will suffice. For more severe over-pronation, look for a “high stability” shoe.

Supination, or under-pronation, means rolling your foot and ankle outward while walking and running. It is characteristic of feet with high arches. This type of foot has a more defined structure, causing the runner to walk on the outsides of his or her feet. Since this is the most rigid part of the foot, this type of runner needs a shoe that is more flexible. These shoes are referred to as “neutral” or “cushioning” shoes. By nature, trail running shoes tend to be stiffer because they need to protect the feet on more challenging terrain. Folks that supinate simply will want to look for a more flexible trail running shoe.


Try the wet foot test to find your foot type.

If you don’t have a local expert to diagnose your gait and foot type, try the wet foot test. Get the bottoms of your feet wet and step on a piece of newspaper or paper towel. Compare your wet footprints to the foot types in the chart below. This will help you determine whether you have a high, low, or neutral arch. A flat foot will leave a complete print of the foot, while a high-arched foot will only imprint the forefoot, the heel, and perhaps a bit of the outside edge.

Also, take a look at the wear patterns on the soles of an old pair of running or walking shoes. If you tend to wear down the inner edges of the bottom of the shoe, you likely over-pronate. If you grind down the outside edges, you supinate. Wear in the middle indicates a neutral arch.

 

Know the Terrain

Next, consider the type of trails and terrain you’ll be tackling.

Kathy Hobbs, executive director of the American Trail Running Association and manager of the Teva U.S. Mountain Running Team, suggests that you “consider the terrain that you will be running and go to a specialty shoe retailer and get their advice on what shoe meets your needs.” You should also consider any injuries past or present when selecting a shoe.

While some runners may get away with using their regular jogging skins from running the roads, you are best off getting a pair of trail-running specific shoes. “Road shoes are meant for a foot strike that is relatively the same over time and distance,” says Hobbs. “Trail shoes are for the uneven, unpredictable, changeable nature of the terrain.”

The various types and models of trail running shoes can seem daunting. Hobbs lists the following shoe features as the most important when considering your needs:


  • Deep lugs and sticky outsoles make for excellent traction on trails.
    Side-to-side support: shoes should give both medial support, toward the arch, and lateral, toward the outside of your foot.
  • Torsional stability and support: for midfoot support and to control over-pronation and supination.
  • Sole lugs for grip: trail surface will play a role in your choice. Dirt, grass, or woodchip trails are less severe, requiring only modest tread. Rockier trails call for deeper, more aggressive lugging. Some shoes tout sticky rubber outsoles for added traction. 
  • A porous upper that lets water out quickly. For very wet and muddy conditions, some trail runners offer a waterproof liner and polyurethane webbing to keep your feet dry.

Keep an eye out for shoes with a gusseted tongue and wrap-around lacing, both make for a snugger fit, keeping out trail debris. Match your shoe’s features to the terrain you expect to encounter regularly and your needs.

 

Know if the Shoe Fits

Now you’ll need to try shoes on. If you are new to trail running, be prepared for trail runners to feel a bit foreign, even if you are accustomed to road running shoes. Trail runners have a lower profile, giving you the sense that you are closer to the ground and better able to feel the earth beneath your feet. Being aware of the ruts and roots on the trail will help you respond appropriately. Trail runners also have wider bases and more aggressive treads.

Hobbs says “consider fit and feel when testing a shoe and if it feels good, provides appropriate support, and good grip.” If the shoe fits, it will feel snug and boot-like in the back, anchoring your heel in, and more like a sandal up front, allowing your toes to wiggle around.

Be sure you have 1/4 to 1/2 inch at the toe end of the shoe to allow for some swelling room. The longer the run, the more your feet will swell. Hobbs emphasizes the importance of sizing, saying that you will “typically need a half size bigger than your street shoes to make sure your toes don’t smash up to the toe box.” It’s the best way to avoid those nasty black and blue toenails.

In the end, you want to pick a trail runner that feels natural on your feet. You shouldn’t be excessively aware of the shoe. If you are, it may not be right for you.

Once you hit the trails you’ll be glad you chose a shoe that fits properly and has all the features necessary for your trail running adventures. A new pair of kicks can make all the difference in creating a successful and fun trail running experience.

 

 

Foot Type Wear Patterns The Issue The Shoe Type

Flat

Your treads show signs of wear on the inside and by the big toe.

Your foot is very flexible and you strike the ground on the outside of your heel and roll inwards, meaning over-pronation. You need some motion control to prevent that inward roll.

High Stability
or
Motion Control

Neutral

Your treads show signs of wear down the middle.

Your foot is neutral, meaning you don’t over-pronate, or you only do so slightly, which is normal. No major correction is needed.

Moderate Stability or
Neutral/Cushioning

High Arch

Your treads show signs of wear on the outside and by the little toe.

Your foot is very rigid and you tend to run on the outsides of your feet, called supination or under-pronation. Your shoes should be well cushioned and flexible to counteract the rigidity of your feet.

Neutral/Cushioning

Filed under: Gear News, Buyers' Guides

Related Content

Trail Running 101  |  The Wet Foot Test  |  Trail Running Shoes

Comments

Jas
164 reviewer rep
13 forum posts
August 21, 2009 at 7:10 a.m. (EDT)

I have been a serious trail runner for about three years. Prior to that I was a rather casual runner; running to stay fit for hiking trips and avoiding road-only runs where possible to prevent boredom! My views on trail shoes have evolved quite a lot in this time, and are still evolving.

I live in the UK and it’s worth noting that we have nothing like the choice of trail shoes that are available in the US. Stability or motion control trail shoes are practically unheard of over here. Years ago a staff member from a running store watched me run and told me I was a neutral runner, so I didn’t give it much thought.

I have taken part in many one day ultras, over distances from 30 to 85 miles. For the longer ones and those not in mountainous areas, until recently my shoe of choice was the Montrail Continental Divide (CD). I used them because I wanted my feet to be well protected and supported.

For more technical running, especially in mountainous areas, I used much more minimal shoes, which give better ‘feel’ and control. In 2007, I did the GL3D, a UK mountain running event covering 65 miles in 3 days, wearing my Inov8 Mudroc 290 ‘fell shoes’; very minimal, snug fitting ‘slippers’, with grippy soles and little cushioning. Beforehand I thought my feet would end up really bashed up, as it had been a dry month and the trails were in hard condition. However, it was a revelation: my feet felt great at the end of it.

Until recently I never questioned my need for very supportive shoes in ultras, despite my GL3D experience. What really made me think was reading Born to Run by Christopher McDougall. It calls into question the whole rationale for ‘modern’ running shoes, although that is only a small part of the book.

Having read Born to Run, and thinking back to my GL3D experience, I realized what a wonderful piece of engineering my feet are: the best I can do is interfere with their function as little as possible. I now run in the lightest shoes I can. Now, my ‘everyday’ shoes are Inov8 F-Lite 230s; basically a racing flat with a ‘light trail’ tread, and on trail ultras, where the jabs from the small stones underfoot get a bit much after a few hours in a thin-soled shoe, I use a more cushioned one, but nothing as ‘engineered’ as the CD.

I am not telling anyone to just throw received wisdom on shoes out of the window, but I know how well ‘going lighter’ has worked for me, and I would encourage anyone reading this to give it some serious thought. Read Born to Run or one of the various articles Christopher has written on shoes (The painful truth about trainers, on the UK Daily Mail’s website is a good one). See what you think.

Share Your Thoughts

September 19, 2014

Please sign in to reply