About | Blog | Forums | People | Free Newsletter
Trailspace is a product review site for outdoor enthusiasts. Use it to find and share great gear.

Gear Explained: Sleeping Bag Shapes, Sizes, Fits

Choosing a sleeping bag requires understanding the different shapes, sizes, and versions available.

 

Shapes


Sleeping bags come in rectangular, semi-rectangular, and mummy shapes. (Illustration by Sarah Lampe)

Rectangular: Not recommended for backpacking, these bags provide greater room to move around and could potentially be more comfortable space wise. They are less efficient at keeping you warm than a mummy bag, due to the extra space. Rectangular bags are better for car camping where it doesn't matter if you bring a heavier, larger bag.

Semi-Rectangular: These are hybrids bags that pair the narrow foot box of a mummy with the large opening and added comfort of a rectangular bag.

Mummy: Wilderness backpackers usually prefer a mummy-shaped bag. These have a closer, tapered fit and a hood to seal the head. Less space means less weight and better insulation because there is a smaller area to heat up.

However, mummy bags can be restrictive for some. View the hip and shoulder girth specs of a bag. The narrower the area, the lighter the bag and the better thermal efficiency. Consider comfort and how much room you need to move around, but remember, too much extra space will make the bag inefficient.

 

Sizes and Fits

Short to Long Length: Bags often are available in short, regular, and long lengths. Some backpackers prefer a little extra length. In winter, the extra space scan be used to store gear that needs to be kept warm, like boots or boot liners. Shorter campers will stay warmer in a bag closer to their actual height. If you're in between two lengths, consider the longer bag.

Two-Person Bags: Several companies make double wide sleeping bags for two to share. They usually are rectangular. If you have a left-zip bag and a right-zip bag with compatible zippers, you can mate two bags together to create your own two-person bag.

Women's: Women may find that a gender-specific bag better mirrors their body shape. These bags may feature a shorter length, narrower shoulders, wider hip area, and extra insulation around the torso and/or feet.

Children's: Kids sleep colder at night than adults, and also need a smaller bag to match their smaller size. Children's bags may include anti-snag zippers and leave out elastic or cords in the hood area for safety.

 

Specialty Bags

Elephant's Foot/Half Bags: An elephant's (or elephant) foot bag is a minimalist half or three-quarter length sleeping bag. The waist high bag is used in conjunction with an insulated, hooded parka and may have suspenders. Elephant foot or half bags are primarily used by alpinists for light and fast travel or emergency bivys.

Over Bags: An over bag is a larger bag you add to the outside of a current sleeping bag for greater warmth. Typically a three-season bag is used inside with a warm weather bag outside. The two bags can be used together as a winter sleeping system or separately for three-season use. Layering two bags can cost less and offer more year-round versatility.

Parka Bags: A few companies manufacture sleeping bags that can be worn as parkas around camp. Simple parka bags feature side zips for the arms and feet, permitting limited mobility. Advanced parka bags feature insulated sleeves and legs, and resemble an insulated suit.

Quilts: Insulated quilts, or blankets, provide insulation only on top (in a regular sleeping bag, the bottom insulation is compressed, making it less efficient). More common among ultalighters, quilts are lighter and more packable than a full bag and are usually shaped to prevent drafts. Some have Velcro tabs or elastic straps to affix them to a sleeping pad. Some are available in two-person versions.

Top Bags: Similar to a quilt, top bags are sleeping bags with no insulation on the bottom, though they do have an empty sleeve on the bottom, designed to slide onto a sleeping pad. With no insulation on the bottom, they are designed for use with a sleeping pad.

 

Liners and Covers

Liners: Sleeping bag liners add warmth and help keep the inside of your bag clean, minimizing wear. Dirt and body oils impair the warmth of the sleeping bag, and it's easier to wash a liner than a whole bag. Thicker synthetic or fleece liners can add up to 15 degrees of warmth to the temperature rating of a bag.

Vapor Barrier Liners (VBL's): Vapor barrier liners are thin, impermeable liners that minimize heat loss caused by evaporating sweat. VBL's prevent bags from losing loft and gaining weight due to sweat freezing in the bag's fill, especially over longer multi-day trips. Since VBL's are non-breathable, they are for use in below freezing temperatures, otherwise they can create a humid, sweaty environment.

Covers: Are waterproof (sometimes waterproof-breathable) shells that are placed over sleeping bags to improve moisture resistance and warmth. Lighter than a bivy sack, they often don't include a hood, bug netting, or other features found in bivy sacks. Tarp campers sometimes make use of sleeping bag covers to keep their sleeping bags dry from outside moisture (however, a waterproof cover will trap interior moisture from the user inside the bag.)

 

(With reporting by Seth Levy)

Filed under: Buyers' Guides

Related Content

Read sleeping bag reviews and product info.

Comments

mikemorrow
314 reviewer rep
1,124 forum posts
March 15, 2011 at 1:36 p.m. (EDT)

Fit is mentioned. but I think it should be added that a mummy bag needs to fit tightly in order to hit its tempature range.

whomeworry
87 reviewer rep
2,224 forum posts
March 15, 2011 at 4:27 p.m. (EDT)

Fit is mentioned. but I think it should be added that a mummy bag needs to fit tightly in order to hit its tempature range.

I respectfully disagree. 

The rating is specified based on the rate heat will dissipate through the insulation layer.  The nature of what lies on each side of the insulation layer is only important as it relates to the temperature differential, not the material nature of what occupies these spaces.  The bag protects dead air inside the bag just as effectiviely as it protects a body.  And dead air is dead air, regardless it is trapped within the down layer or trapped inside the bag.  While moving around may displace excess air volume inside a bag, this happens regardless if the bag is snug or oversized.  If you think a bag is ineffective at protecting air space inside of it, try draping your bag over your tent in the hot midday sun; you will realize it is capable of providing the same insulating qualities to the tent interior – which is mostly air – only in this case it keeps the hot sun from heating the tent interior.

The reason for the perception that an oversized bag is less warm has to do with intimate contact with the bag.  Just like the blankets in your bed at home, the layers that touch you become warmed to skin temperature, but as you move you contact different surfaces that are warmed to the ambient temperature under your covers, and obviously are cooler than your skin.  These quickly warm, however, just like at home.  Wearing long johns and socks to bed will almost completely eliminate this temporary discomfort, in the backcountry as well as at home.  Thus a -40 bag is a -40 bag, regardless of its size and that of the occupant.

Ed

Explorer Robby
141 reviewer rep
218 forum posts
March 15, 2011 at 8:48 p.m. (EDT)

If a bag is too tight, it can make the insulation less effective by streching it, having the same effect as crushing it. A hood or draft tube are the best ways of retaining warmeth in my experience. If a bag is loose fitting your body will have to warm the dead air (which it will), but if the bag can not hold the heat, it will not be warm. One the coldest nights I ever had was when I let my wife (who moves constantly in her sleep) talk me into zipping our sleeping bags together. This created a gap at the hoods the let the warm air out everytime she moved. Did it once. Never again.

Share Your Thoughts

April 24, 2014

Please sign in to reply