Choosing a Lightweight Summer Bag

I sleep warm. Usually very warm.

I’m also on a bit of an ounce-counting kick lately, and yet I continue to haul a 3+ pound, 20-degree sleeping bag on just about every trip. My EMS MM 20, has served me well for years, in all seasons, and I always stuff it into my pack without a second thought. Last week I finally realized the obvious: the bag is total overkill for summer trips, and even for late spring and early fall. Even in its advanced stage of loftlessness, I usually end up sleeping with the bag mostly unzipped, my arms and one leg exposed to avoid overheating. Often I just sleep on top of it. I’ve only used the hood a couple times, in winter.

So this week I went shopping for a new summer bag. I wanted something lightweight, with a high temperature rating and a minimum of features. That meant no hood, no pockets, and possibly no insulation on the bottom. Must-haves were a partial or full zipper for ventilation control, and down fill (mostly because of down’s superior packability). I looked at bags from a number of manufacturers, eventually narrowing it down to:

  • Big Agnes Horse Thief 20 oz., 50-degree top bag: an early contender at a decent price, but I didn’t like the fact that it wouldn’t work with my existing rectangular sleeping pad.

  • MontBell U.L. Alpine Down Hugger Thermal Sheets 12 oz., no published temperature rating: the lightest bag I looked at, with a full zip and only 0.3 oz. less down than MontBell’s 50-degree hooded model.

  • Feathered Friends Vireo: 17 oz. (avg), 45-degree hoodless mummy. Zipperless design is intended to be used together with a FF down jacket.

  • Nunatak Gear Arc Edge: 12 oz. (long), 40-degree down quilt. While the quilt concept is intriguing, I don’t think I’m quite sold.

  • Western Mountaineering MityLite 1lb. 10 oz., 40-degree mummy: continuous baffles allow you to shift down from the bottom to the top of the bag for added insulation. But a 40 degree rating and 12 oz. of down put this bag on the warm and heavy side in this search.

In the end, the extreme light weight and full zip of the MontBell Thermal Sheets won me over. (The reasonable price and ready availability also helped to reinforce my decision.) The new bag should be arriving today and I’m planning on taking it to Utah later this month.

Of course, that light weight comes at a cost. I am a little concerned by the lack of insulation – only 4.6 oz. of 725-fill down. Do I really sleep as warm as I think I do? We'll find out soon.

Update: Read my review of the MontBell bag.


Filed under: Gear News

Comments

ministercreek
153 reviewer rep
460 forum posts
October 11, 2006 at 12:39 a.m. (EDT)

I recently purchased the ALPS Mountaineering +35 degree Clearwater model.

Got to use it some this past Summer camping here in southern Wisconsin. I plan to use it on future backpacking trips. I purchased it mainly for the "fit" and weight. Pretty light and compact for a synthetic bag.

And no, I don't work for ALPS Mountaineering nor am I affilated with this Company. My years of experience with ALPS gear conviced me they make pretty good gear, that's all.

This post has been locked and is not accepting new comments