I originally bought these boots for a hunting trip…
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $225 USD
I originally bought these boots for a hunting trip and found that they were probably the most comfortable boots I had worn in a very long time. Many days and mile spent at higher elevations in the Colorado and Utah Rockies as well as a Grand Canyon rim-to rim hike with never so much as a hot spot. I would definitely recommend them to others!
- Cork footbed molds to your individual foot
- Very sturdy to hold up to whatever you can dish out
- Not as light as other boots
I have had these boots for a few years, and have put…
Materials: leather, Gore-tex
Use: long day hikes, heavy backpacking
Break-in Period: little or none
Weight: 3.6 pounds
Price Paid: $185
I have had these boots for a few years, and have put a lot of miles on them. I have hiked 14ers, I have hiked Half-Dome, and have hiked to the bottom of the Grand Canyon in them. I have hiked in them with a heavy pack. So far, I haven't had any blisters or other complaints whatsoever.
Unlike the other reviewer, I kept the original footbeds, and have found them to be satisfactory. The boots look great, are very comfortable, and have held up very well, in spite of tough trail conditions.
If you like traditional heavy leather hiking boots, like I do, you will like the Cabela's Perfekt. The Germans know how to make stuff.
Very nice hiking boots made by Meindl. They have a…
Break-in Period: 3 Weeks
Weight: 3 lbs approx
Price Paid: $190
Very nice hiking boots made by Meindl. They have a replaceable footbed made from cork/poron that molds to your foot over time, though I have replaced them with Ed Veistures, Sole footbeds (wich I would rate at 5+ stars).
The boots have held up great over time and I would definitely buy another pair when they wear out. I tip the scales at 205 and am 6'2" and usually carry a pack between 30-40 pounds, I believe they carry the load great. The ankle support and stiffness of the sole are great and provide plenty of traction and anti roll on hills. The size 12 I have is true to fit with plenty of room in the toe box area and have a great laceing system holds the heels firm both uphill and downhill.
I could not find Meindl boots in the US, but I understand they are available in Canada. I understand these Cabela's/Meindl boots may be the same as the Colorado GTX that Meindl sells as their own. If I had the ability to shop models, I would have liked to have tried out the Island Pro or the Burma models. Some friends from the Netherlands had these boots with them last time they visited and said they were very popular in Europe. They held up well for them in our hiking in the Olympic Natnl Park. Great Boots I would rate them as very high quality,comfort and workmanship and they are made in Germany.
The only reason I'm taking off a star is because ultimately…
Materials: Combination smooth leather and nubuck leather
Use: Meant for "extensive walking and moderate trekking"
Break-in Period: A couple of days of walking around
Weight: 3.6 lbs.
Price Paid: $130 (on sale)
The only reason I'm taking off a star is because ultimately these boots didn't fit my wide feet. I'm putting this review up as an aid to people who might have similar problems finding a fit for their high-instep, wide at the ball, long-toed, narrow heeled feet.
These boots are quite impressive. The uppers are a combination of smooth leather around the laces, with a rand made of rough-out leather. The lacing system is well done.
The boots are tall for a hiking boot, at 8", which gives them great ankle support for their weight. The soft Achiles tendon cutout area is well-designed. I didn't feel any constriction at all.
The very comfy footbed is made of cork, is very nicely supportive and provides great cushioning. It's supposed to mold itself to the shape of your foot, but I didn't keep the boots long enough to be able to confirm this.
The stitching seems very solid, and the (glued-on, molded) sole looks tough, even though it's a Meindl sole, not a Vibram or Skywalk.
I would be giving these boots a solid 5, except that they just didn't fit me. I have wide (EE) feet, with a not-so-big heel and ankle (shaped sort of like a slice of pizza with a high instep). This makes it very tricky for me to find a boot that fits. This boot came very close, except that there is a seam on the inner lining that goes right over the bony area at my pinky toes. The boots feel like they place a tight ring wrapped around the widest area at the ball of my foot. After a couple of hours, this makes my feet very uncomfortable. It's not that the toe box is small, because it's actually quite roomy (another indication of a very intelligent design). It's just that the area right where the lacing starts over the ball of the foot is very low. I guess I have too high an instep for these boots.
I would imagine that if you have more normal-shaped feet, these boots would be a great deal at their current sale price ($60 less than the new 2005 model). They are very well made and look like they should last a long time.
Cabela's offers a return policy where you can try the boots out for up to a couple of weeks on rugs or other non-challenging surfaces and return the boots if they don't work out for you. This is quite fair, but not the best you can do.
L.L.Bean and Sierra Trading Post offer a 100% guarantee that allows you to return boots even if you've taken them out on the trail. I'll be trying a pair of Alico boots from Sierra...
Right now I'm breaking in a pair of Danner Mountain Light II, and I'll report on how these do once I've taken them out on the trail.
To those of you who can simply go to your local sporting goods store and find lots of boots that fit you: I envy you!