About | Blog | Forums | People | Free Newsletter
Trailspace is a product review site for outdoor enthusiasts. Use it to find and share great gear.

Merrell Switchback Gore-Tex

8 reviews
5-star:   5
4-star:   0
3-star:   0
2-star:   1
1-star:   2
0

These are flat out the worst boots I have ever put…

Rating: rated 1 of 5 stars
Source: received it as a personal gift

Summary

These are flat out the worst boots I have ever put my feet in. They rubbed the tops of my foot raw in less than a mile and I couldn't put my feet back in them after this experience. I was told by Merrell there's a break-in period, but for a very expensive pair of hikers these are a disaster!

Switching production to China may have saved money but I'll never buy another pair of Merrell boots.

Pros

  • Nice looking

Cons

  • Extremely pooor construction

Worst boots ever. Period. Very uncomfortable and poorly constructed. I have read some very positive reviews of this boot, which leads me to believe quality control in China is just not up to par. If this were a 50 dollar pair of boots I would not have wasted my time writing this, but these boots are going in the trash.

0

I'll say flat out that I am disappointed with this…

Rating: rated 2 of 5 stars
Materials: leather, vibram
Use: multiday trips in forest and alpine; snowshoeing
Break-in Period: none, really
Price Paid: $200

I'll say flat out that I am disappointed with this boot, particularly with its construction. It may look superficially pretty, but the construction is so poor that the boots fell apart fairly quickly. I have had the boots since late 2007, and have used them perhaps 15-20 times, for a total of no more than 30 days.

1. When the boots were new, I used them in the city during a snow storm. After 2-3 days of this, several of the metal lace eyelets over the arch became badly corroded by salt and were almost entirely eaten away. The jagged edges left over tore at the boot laces. Perhaps this wasn't in keeping with the boots' intended use, but I think that the eyelets should have been made out of stainless steel or at the very least given a protective coating.

2. After an overnight trip that involved scrambling over some rocky terrain, I noticed that several of the Vibram lugs on the forefoot of the boot had been ripped off. This boot uses two different densities of vibram, one of which is supposed to be stickier and provide more traction. It was this sticky vibram that ripped off under the forefoot. The interface between the sticky and non-sticky vibram appears to be a weak point on the sole.

3. A few days ago, I got back from an overnight snowshoeing trip and realized that on BOTH boots the stitching holding the leather upper to the plastic/rubber heel counter had torn away, leaving the back of the boots open to the elements and completely destroying its waterproofness, which wasn't fantastic to begin with (non-goretex version). Upon closer inspection of this ruined section, the stitching appears to be very poor quality: there was only one row of stitches holding together this critical seam, and the individual stitches were quite far apart. I can't be sure, but the stitching failure here may be related to the fact that I have gotten the boots pretty wet several times. Maybe the stitching rotted?

After roughly 1.5 years of use the boots are now essentially useless. Poor construction wasn't the only issue though: when wet, the boots would become progressively looser and sloppier, making going downhill on uneven sections very difficult. I'm not sure if this is the fault of the boots themselves or the laces which came with them.

0

I bought these boots in preparation for a Grand Canyon…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars

I bought these boots in preparation for a Grand Canyon trip. I was having problems with my feet, and I needed something with enough support to protect a problem area on my foot, but lightweight enough to not weigh me down to much, as I am not an experienced hiker.

I started breaking them in, and the heel was really bugging me. Did some small half day hikes and had to use moleskin on my heels. As my Grand Canyon trip got closer I stared to have concerns for my feet. I wear a 15, and you can't just go buy another pair of boots easily. I was wearing the boots to work everyday, and they slowly started to feel better.

When I got to the Grand Canyon, I was nervous that my feet wouldn't be able to take it. Hiked down South Kabob Trail, hiked to Ribbon Falls, hiked back out on Bright Angel, drove to Havasupai and hiked down and out in one long day. Hiked about 32 hours in 4 days, and didn't even have the hint of a blister or any other discomfort in my feet (don't even talk about the leg muscles).

Since then I have hiked a lot more, and have had nothing but good experiences with these boots. I was actually considering custom made boots, but now I just buy Merrell.

0

Saw in a magazine at a hiking store and had them ordered…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Price Paid: $150

Saw in a magazine at a hiking store and had them ordered the next day. I typically wear around an 11.5 and these hit the mark, with a near perfect fit at size 11.5.

First things I noticed were that these boots were a few inches taller then my previous pair and started to rub a little which lasted throughout the first week (Break in)on my leg, but quickly subsided. After that it was on to the torture test which was running a 3000 ft water line under ground in absolutely miserable conditions, wet/muddy as hell/cold for 4 days straight. My feet were kept warm and extremely comfortable without a single incident.

Several hiking trips later and one backpacking expedition confirmed my original conclusions that these boots are definitely keepers. They have these wonderful toe buffers making down hills climbs a breeze. I've had these for about a month now still without issue, so as usual time will indeed probably tell, but for now I'm extremely pleased.

0

Hi, Bought these boots over the web after having tried…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Use: Heavy backpacking
Break-in Period: None
Price Paid: $125

Hi, Bought these boots over the web after having tried on in-store multiple boots at REI. Originally bought the Asolo 520 but they hurt my baby toes with more walking, and concluded they were for European and not American feet. Merrell boots fit American feet so they tend to be a little wider. Also a size "9" means a "9" and not 9.5". I have had big problem with heel slippage so for me that was very important.

Anyway, these boots can be worn out of the box. They require little break-in time. Day one with a 40lbs pack I took them over Thunderbolt pass in King Canyon NP. No heal blisters so no suffering. I would recommend these boots. Not sure how long they will last but so far so good.

0

I bought these boots and wore them around town for…

Rating: rated 1 of 5 stars
Materials: leather/gore-tex

I bought these boots and wore them around town for a couple of days to start breaking them in. I took them on their first hike on moderate terrain and found them to severely rub the back of my heels on uphill climbs. The worst part of all is the materials and construction of these boots. I had mine decently tight to hold my foot, and the shoelace ripped though the metal mount at there different locations. Whether I had the laces too tight or not, THIS SHOULD NEVER HAPPEN in a pair of boots. I will never buy another pair of Merrells after this experience.

0

These boots by far are one of the most comfortable…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Materials: Gore-Tex
Use: dayhikes, rough trail, backpacking
Break-in Period: 10-15 miles of easy hiking
Price Paid: $150

These boots by far are one of the most comfortable hiking boots that I have ever worn. When these boots are on your feet you can traverse any trail in confidence. I don't think that you have to get the Gore-tex version. I am sure that the leather version is more than suitable.

My one problem with these boots, I have flat feet and these boots lack proper arch support. This is a relativly easy problem to fix just a Dr. Scholls insert and they are perfect. Otherwise break-in period was only about 10-15 miles of easy trail hiking and they fit like a glove.

0

This is a great boot....I took them out on a 13-mile…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Price Paid: $159

This is a great boot....I took them out on a 13-mile hike thru trails covered in snow and mud. Several times I was scrambling across wet granite and with a 50lb pack on I didn't have to worry about losing my footing at all! Great grip and tough, waterproof leather are going to make this pair of boots a real keeper.

Know someone who might be interested in this?
Share it on email, Facebook, Google+, or Twitter.
If you've owned or used a Merrell Men's Switchback Gore-Tex, please share your experience.

Merrell Men's Switchback Gore-Tex

Discontinued

The Men's Switchback Gore-Tex has been discontinued.

previously retailed for:
$74.96 - $150.00

The Merrell Men's Switchback Gore-Tex is not available from the stores we monitor. It was last seen August 6, 2008 at EMS.

If you're looking for a new backpacking boot, check out the best reviewed current models.