About | Blog | Forums | People | Free Newsletter
Trailspace is a product review site for outdoor enthusiasts. Use it to find and share great gear.

Red Wing Irish Setter

6 reviews
5-star:   3
4-star:   3
3-star:   0
2-star:   0
1-star:   0
0

Great boots, tough soles and very comfortable, especially…

Rating: rated 4.5 of 5 stars
Source: received it as a personal gift

Summary

Great boots, tough soles and very comfortable, especially given the price!

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Breathable
  • Durable

Cons

  • Mesh lower limits waterproofing

I've had my Irish Setters since about 2008, and have put them through hundreds of miles of abuse. From Idaho backcountry 13-mile days, Utah 10 milers and countless miles of East Coast mud, streams, and sticks these boots haven't let me down yet.

Mine are mid-calf with a mix of leather and mesh lowers, which does hurt the waterproofing. While they are GoreTex lined, I have admittedly not cared for them properly with regards to re-applying proofing sprays. The soles are starting to wear significantly but do not suffer from a lack of traction or comfort. The insoles have lost much of their cush under my big toe and after significant downhills the ball of my foot is tired.

Fit is spot-on and very little break-in was required.

Support is also excellent. I have a weak ankle and while it will roll some in these boots, I have yet to exert it to the point of discomfort.

Highly recommended!

0

Bought mine in 1978. Still wearing them today. Had…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Price Paid: less than 100

Bought mine in 1978. Still wearing them today. Had to have the Vibram soles reattached in 1990.

They are as good as new, very comfortable, still do not leak and I wore them quail hunting last week.

0

There have been more than one Irish Setter boots sold…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Materials: Oil tanned leather
Use: Caving and wet weather day hiking
Break-in Period: One month of light hiking.
Weight: 4 pounds for the pair
Price Paid: $150

There have been more than one Irish Setter boots sold by Red Wing. The pair I owned were purchased in the 1970s, and were built like high topped US Army military boots, but were made with oil tanned leather, Norwegian welts and Vibram soles. They were originally intended as hunting boots.

I wore them as caving boots in muddy, wet caves in the eastern US. They survived four years of monthly abuse and kept going until I finally blew them out.

So far as I know Red Wing still sells these boots. The boots to buy do not have cloth or Gore-Tex uppers, and are higher than standard hiking boots.

0

These boots are outstanding. On my father's advice,…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Materials: Leather
Use: Rough trail/Rocky
Break-in Period: None
Price Paid: $90

These boots are outstanding. On my father's advice, he wore them all of his life in geological field work, I purchased a pair for hiking and outdoor recreational use. No break-in period whatsoever. With a polypro sock and wool your feet will stay completely toasty. The sole is a heavy-duty vibram which looks as good today as it did when I bought them 11 years ago. Toe gets scuffed a bit and I have to pay special attention to keeping that clean and conditioned. I will definitely buy another pair...in 10 years when this pair finally wears out!

0

As my first hiking boot, I didn't know what to get,…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Materials: Full-grain leather w/Gore-Tex
Use: Rugged Terrain (Philmont) with 40lb. pack
Break-in Period: 2 months-walking around school-cutting lawns
Weight: 3.5 lbs
Price Paid: $90 on sale, $160 is reg.

As my first hiking boot, I didn't know what to get, but I found this pair on sale for $90 and figured I didn't have much to lose. After putting on a 100 miles @ Philmont, I have no complaints--no leaks, blisters--the toe box is very hard leather, but scuffs easily. I coated them with aquaseal (voids the warranty against leaks), but they have kept me dry thus far. Note--Redwing is the same company that makes Vasque boots.

0

Well, what can I say? They have gotten me to the top…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Materials: leather
Use: climbing/long distance backpacing
Break-in Period: zero
Weight: 3 lbs pr
Price Paid: $200

Well, what can I say? They have gotten me to the top of Mount Rainier and to the bottom of the Grand Canyon. I used them on my through hike of the 2650 Pacific Crest Trail. They are good for at least 2000 miles of trail. I have even done 5.8 pitches in them. No break in required and never a blister. Last forever, comfortable, multi use. Who could ask for anything more?

Know someone who might be interested in this?
Share it on email, Facebook, Google+, or Twitter.
If you've owned or used a Red Wing Irish Setter, please share your experience.

Red Wing Irish Setter

reviewers paid:
$90.00 - $200.00

The Red Wing Irish Setter is not available from the stores we monitor.

If you're looking for a new backpacking boot, check out the best reviewed current models.