Reviews

5

The Vasque Breeze 2.0 GTX is a very comfortable sport…

Rating: rated 3 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $89.97 for latest, $149.99 for first two

Summary

The Vasque Breeze 2.0 GTX is a very comfortable sport shoe best suited for hiking and lightweight backpacking. This is 4-star comfort with 2.5-star durability, but it fits the niche I need: a low-top hybrid boot/shoe that accepts my custom orthotics and wears comfortably out of the box. I've been using these since mid-2015 and just bought the third pair.

Pros

  • Fits well for me / lots of volume for orthotics
  • Comfortable out of box
  • Breathable
  • Available in Wide widths
  • Works well with under-strap gaiters

Cons

  • Durability
  • Value
  • Hit or miss quality control
  • So-so traction on slippery surfaces until sole wears a bit


DSCN1502.jpg                                                   [click picture to enlarge]

About the shoe:

  • Uppers are 1.8mm nubuck leather and mesh
  • Sole is Vibram
  • Insole is dual density EVA
  • Weight 1 lb (.45 kg)  per shoe

Fit and Comfort

For me, footwear is mostly about fit. I may occasionally need a certain feature or specific aspect for a given application, but it’s all for naught if it doesn’t fit. I wear custom molded orthotics which makes finding a good fit double-hard since my orthotic is very thick and I need a lot of volume. Vasque offers the Breeze in a wide width and that model fits the bill.

These are among the most out-of-box-comfortable shoes I’ve tried. I can buy a new pair and immediately start cranking out the miles with no break-in worry. (Just bought my third pair in the last two years.)

Here are a few photos to illustrate what I'm up against in shoe fitting and why the volume is so important for me.

On the left is the stock insert and on the right is my custom orthotic:


DSCN1598.jpg
DSCN1599.jpg
DSCN1600.jpg                                                 [click picture to enlarge]

Durability

Though I am using this shoe for backpacking in all seasons and with all pack weights, I still find it lacking in durability. Notably, the seams around the toe box start deteriorating right away. The threads visible in that toe seam appear to break very easily and with minimal abrasion.

The fabric in the heel wears quickly for me also. On my first pair I applied Tear-Aid tape to the heel in the Achilles contact area to cover fabric tears on both shoes.

At about the 500-mile mark these shoes are noticeably less supportive and by 700 miles they are falling apart. This is on par with most trail runners I've used and I expected more durability given the marketing claims of boot/shoe hybrid status.

This pair has a little over 700 miles on them and the photos show the seam that's likely to fail soon:

DSCN1603.jpg

DSCN1602.jpg                                             [click picture to enlarge]

Quality Control (yes, this gets a header)

This is a very strange issue with this brand/model. I’m on my third pair of these but have actually purchased five pairs of them (four via mail-order). Two had to be returned because of defects out of the box. The defects were both stitching and seam related.

As I mentioned, seams are the first thing to break down on these, so if it’s already an issue before I’ve worn them that’s a non-starter. I have no insights into the manufacturing chain, but all models I’ve bought were made in China.

Water Resistance

I’m not a fan of GTX liners in general and didn’t buy these shoes because of them (would have preferred a non-GTX model actually but they don’t offer one). So this wasn’t something I was looking for and really don’t see a great deal of value in waterproofing a low top shoe.

In any event, this seems to be just as hit and miss as the overall quality amongst the three pairs I’ve used. The first pair was waterproof for about the first 100 miles of use then leaked badly. The second pair had a right toe leak almost from day one. This third pair actually seems fine so far (but I’ve not put 100 miles on them yet).


DSCN1496.jpg                                                [click picture to enlarge]

Breathability

As you might expect from a product called the Breeze, these are quite breathable. I would say they are the most breathable GTX shoes I’ve used to date.


DSCN1503.jpg                                                 [click picture to enlarge]

Traction

I’ve never used a Vibram sole that I thought was exceptional in this area and these aren’t either. You really have to watch it on wet rocks and slick logs until the sole wears down some. After several dozen miles of mixed terrain I find the sole softens a bit and becomes much more grippy. The traction is fine on dry surfaces.

This was an interesting comparison. The shoe on the left has over 700 miles on it compared to the one on the right that has less than 100:
DSCN1594.jpg                                                 [click picture to enlarge]
Using with gaiters:

I nearly always use gaiters when backpacking and these shoes accept the various kinds I use. I glue a Velcro strip to the heel for Dirty Girl attachments and the generous arch area in the sole allows the use of under-strap gaiters (which I prefer in wet and/or snowy conditions).


DSCN1591.jpg
DSCN1497.jpg
Conclusions

You might wonder why I gave these a 3-star rating and keep buying them based on all my negative callouts….well, they’re comfortable and fit! It’s all about the fit. Despite the quality issues and less than desirable durability, I find the comfort and fit to trump all. If I come across something better I’ll switch, but so far, these are my best option and I’m willing to replace them every 500 to 700 miles.

Testing Conditions:

I've used these as my primary backpacking shoes since mid 2015 in all weather, seasons and locations. Including: my local Smoky Mountains,  the Elk Mountains of Colorado, Glacier National Park Montana, Ocala National Forest Florida, in the heart of summer and in snow with high gaiters, in rain, in sleet, etc...

Of course these are not intended for deep winter use but I've gotten away with adding vapor barrier liners underneath and tall gaiters over pants for use in the snow and cold.

About the tester:

I’m an obsessively avid backpacker and hit 30-40 short trips per year, in all seasons, usually covering about 1,000 miles per year. I mostly play in the Southern Appalachians but will typically do a Western USA trip once per year. I’ve been backpacking at this intensity for almost a decade now. If interested in where I go, I’ve posted a lot of Trip Reports here on Trailspace. And now that I think about it, I was wearing these shoes in nearly every report from summer '15 on. :)

20161210_120214.jpg

DSCN0031.jpg


DSCN9859.jpg

Jake W

Great review Pat! Out of curiosity, have you ever tried dabbing some seam sealer (pre failure) on that area that keeps falling apart?


6 months ago
Patman

Hey Thanks Jake. I haven't tried that preemptively yet but I did squeeze Shoe Goo into the holes before going to Glacier last summer. It seemed to help for a few weeks. It's a good idea; I may do just that.


6 months ago
Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

Nice review, Patman! I can understand why you keep buying something that works for you, even if it's not perfect.


6 months ago
G00SE MODERATOR

I Shoe Goo all the seams of my caving boots before I cave with them. Definitely extends the life of them.


6 months ago