Definitely not my first choice for seriously cold…
Fill: Duck down
Temperature Rating: -40 C
Source: Issued to me
Price Paid: $800
Definitely not my first choice for seriously cold weather.
- I would choose a 5 Star only if there was nothing else.
- Amazingly heavy
- Cheap duck down of unspecified fill power
- Quilted construction
- No hood
- No draft tube
- Not true to temperature rating
- Flat, rectangular bag
During the winter months my job demands that I patrol by snow machine a vast area of the Canadian Arctic, but before doing so, I was ordered to buy some “proper” winter gear. This included, among other things, a Canada Goose parka (see my reviews of the Snow Mantra Parka and Tundra Pants), and a Woods 5 Star sleeping bag.
Now, Woods has been around for over a century and has made some half decent gear in its day, in the form of heavy canvas tents and packs designed for prospectors and other stalwarts of the old school. I even own some of their equipment myself, used mostly for canoeing.
My uncle owned a 5 Star sleeping bag when I was young. Back then it didn’t even have a zipper (Woods believed zippers were a newfangled fad that wouldn’t last); instead it was festooned with snaps to close its rather cumbersome canvas fabric and wool-blend blanket liner. Then, as now, it had no hood.
When I was in Boy Scouts, some 40 years ago, we used the 5 Star sleeping bags too, but like my uncle, our winter camping excursions were limited to heated cabins and tents. I remember how cold we all were when the fire went out and we lay shivering in our 5 Star sleeping bags until the call of nature roused someone out to start the fire again.
In fact, the venerable 5 Star sleeping bag has followed me throughout my life and I will admit that there is a certain rustic charm to rolling out a 25 lb bag and crawling in; the same kind of impractical charm as a chuck wagon or a Commodore 64. And the 5 Star certainly seems to hold on to the myth. So, although I have only recently become an owner of one, I have used them on many occasions throughout my life.
My new Woods 5 Star has not changed much with a temperature rating of -40°C, which at first glance should mean something, but without a hood or drawstring this claim is highly suspect. No self-respecting manufacturer would ever produce a winter bag without a hood and, with no means to close the bag around your neck, whatever heat which may be trapped in it would escape whenever you rolled over.
Since the bag is basically flat and rectangular, and the human body is not, there is no place to put your feet, which if you sleep on your back stick straight up. Or, rather would stick up if there was a foot box built in. But, no, there is no foot box, no hood, no collar, no drawstring, and no draft tube against the zipper.
In fact, the 5 Star has none of the standard features of a modern winter sleeping bag. The weight as well leaves something to be desired. At over 20 lbs, with a reported 3.5 lbs of duck down (fill power conveniently unspecified) it’s a behemoth. But, because the down is spread out over such a big area, it only has 5 inches of loft and since loft is warmth the 5 star should be rated as a summer/fall bag only. (My apologies to the other reviewer, but -8°F is a long ways away from -40°F.)
This is why my 5 Star now sits in my office collecting dust. When I go out on winter journeys in the Arctic I take my 25-year-old NF Inferno sleeping bag. At 5 lbs, 3.5 of which is 700 fill goose down, and 12 inches of loft it has never failed me, even in truly severe cold in excess of minus 50C.
I guess when it comes to the 5 Star the only caveat is that I did not have to pay for this with my own money and I wound up with a new quilt for the bed, which is all it seems to be good for.
Update for 2012.
A while ago I was lucky enough to go on a 600km winter trip through the mountains, crossing two Canadian Territories. Everyone with me brought their 5 Star bags and I had my old NF Inferno bag. How they all laughed when they saw how small and light weight it was!
I watched closely the people's sleeping habits and inspite of the fact that they slept fully clothed and had the wood stove going all night in the tent, everyone complained about the cold, everyone that is except me who slept warm as always in my NF bag. The only problem I had was the noise of people getting up during the night to feed the stove.
Sadly, the experience was lost on everyone as they still travel with these things... they also carry big wood stoves. And for those who read the other reviewers comments, whiskey freezes at -34.4°C or -30°F.
The warmest sleeping bag on the market. I used this…
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $500
The warmest sleeping bag on the market.
- It has two down bags, so you can remove one if it is a bit warmer.
I used this bag in Northern Saskatchewan while working in geology. The temperature was minus sixty degrees Fahrenheit. I was cool, but at that temperature, what do you expect?
This is the best sleeping bag I have ever owned.
The sleeping bag is bulky, but will endure a lot of punishment. The bag can open up fully and be used as a comforter if necessary. This bag will keep you warm at -40 degrees.
i bought my 5 Star in January of 1977 and retired…
i bought my 5 Star in January of 1977 and retired it this last spring. i have many stories to tell about that bag; it became more of a friend than a piece of equipment.
i have worked in bush camps all over the north and canadian arctic. i'm not sure what the coldest night's temperature actually was - the diesel fuel feeding the heater froze, as did a bottle of whiskey (well - half froze anyway.) (somewhere south of -60 i guess)
suffice it to say that that was the most comfortable sleeping bag, winter or summer i have ever had. i never was first out to stoke the fire in the morning. if the new bag is as good as the old and the size/weight are not a problem, then this should be the last bag you ever buy.
I am trying to find another one and any info on the…
Temperature Rating: Hell Freezing Over
Weight: 7-8 pounds
Price Paid: $15 garage sale
I am trying to find another one and any info on the company I can find. I bought mine at an estate sale years ago. It is canvas with an eiderdown fill and wool liner. I have camped off a horse with this bag from central Texas to the Colorado Rockies and it's one of the most utilitarian pieces of equipment I have ever owned, provided that weight is not a factor.
If anyone has info to share I would love to hear it. Finding info on the Woods Company (like a website for crying out loud) has been, for me at least, as fruitful as searching for The Holy Grail.
I used my Woods Arctic 5 star on a recent Wyoming…
Design: large rectangular
Fill: duck down
Temperature Rating: -40F
Price Paid: $410 US
I used my Woods Arctic 5 star on a recent Wyoming elk hunt. We had snow and temps down to -8F. I didn't even have to zip this bag up! It is truly a cold weather bag and I'm sure will meet the manufacturer's claims of comfort to -40F. The comfort and quality are excellent and I would recommend this bag to anyone wanting to stay warm in COLD weather.