8:53 a.m. on August 26, 2008 (EDT)
Re: Backpacking with a pooch...
Well, that depends on how well your dog is trained for the most part. I haven't experienced the dog actually attracting animals just by his presence.
Only speaking from my own experience here, but usually when I have had problems it was because the dog was running out of camp or off trail sticking his nose where it really didn't belong.
In all fairness to the dog he was just curious and excited by all the new scents and sounds.
Some dogs are bad about confronting other animals such as Raccoons or Snakes. Some dogs will run around marking all the trees.
In any case, these little forays can create problems for the dog and dog owner alike. Raccoon or Opossum bites can be particularly nasty and there is always the risk of Rabies to the owner of the dog as he tries to break up the fight.
Dogs should be trained to stay away from snakes, mine is trained to bark if he spots or smells a snake, and then come to my side, this gives the snake a chance to get away without being confronted by the dog.
Snakes will generally get out of your way if you do not provoke them. Sometimes they stay put, especially Copperheads that are sunning on the trail early in the morning, again, this is just what I have experienced in the areas I go to.
A dog will help keep your camp from being invaded by critters during the night, just his scent seems to be enough for most critters to stay away. I haven't found anything to stop rodents completely though, for me this is mostly a problem around established shelters and tent areas.
A dog has a lot of instincts and natural abilities that can be VERY beneficial to us in the back country, but only if your dog is well trained and after you have spent some time observing your dogs behavior on a few trips.
A dogs hearing, keen sense of smell, ability to back track his own scent, and other abilities are very useful to me especially on solo trips. My dog routinely hears things long before I do, or things that I would not have heard at all.
I find this reassuring, especially on solo trips at night.
A dog will also look in the direction he hears things, and can zero in on that direction long before humans can.
The sound of running water, an injured or lost hiker, thunder, movement in the brush, ect.
I am also convinced my dog can smell water.
I personally don't take my dog on trails that see a lot of use, or in state parks, ect. Dogs in these areas are more of a nuisance to other hikers than anything else.
I only take him in more pristine/remote areas as a companion and a tool for me to use to stay safe, and mostly on solos.
My dog is trained to stay by my side for the most part, he does wander around while we hike, but not too far.
I have fitted his collar with both a red strobe and a bell. This helps me keep track of him and helps let other animals in the area know that we are around, this is very important in bear territory. If going to an area with bears you should keep the dog strictly by your side, or at least very close.
So it's not so much that you need a dog to scare away dangerous animals as it is using their exceptional abilities to smell what you can not smell, and hear what you can not hear, see what you can not see (especially at night), and using that information to make better decisions that will make your trip more enjoyable and keep you safer.
But only a well trained dog will be of any use to you in that regard. You must bond with the dog, be his/her best friend, and spend time observing their body language so you can interpret that into useful information.
Hope that was useful CSamrock