6:48 p.m. on December 22, 2011 (EST)
Rick you make alot of valid points, and I will do my best to address each one.
For starters it doesn't matter if your using a tent, tarp, hammock, bivy, or lean to, in order to use any shelter option in winter or any season for that matter you have to have the appropiate gear for the conditions. For example, no one is going to go winter backpacking without a good sleeping pad such as a exped downmat 9, or other combinations of ccf and inflatable etc or whatever your personal combo is for winter. No one is going to go out without a good sleeping bag rated to whatever temps you will be in. And also no one is going to cowboy camp in the open during a bad storm without any shelter.
I'd be willing to bet that I could set up my tent quicker than you could set up you hammock/tarp.
I can set up my entire hammock setup in less than 5 minutes on average. I pack my hammock and quilts together in one stuff sack(the quilts stay on the hammock while I am out on a trip). I can have the hammock hung between two trees in about 30 seconds on average after I find 2 suitable trees. The tarp is in a seperate stuff sack with lines already attached. I can have the tarp hung and staked out in 2-3 minutes on average. Then I can climb in my hammock and quickly adjust the quilts by just pulling on them as they are on shockcord channels and slide with a tug. Entire setup time including unpacking from the pack is usually less than 5 minutes regardless of the weather condtions. It is really fast and really easy, and no knots to tie. If you include time looking for trees total time is usually about 15 minutes from search to lounging in the hammock. Or you can hang the tarp first, which i do in foul weather.
Not too mention, if one is stuck in one spot for a prolonged period due to weather I wouldn't want to spend multiple days in a hammock.
How is it better spending prolonged periods stuck in a tent? You can sit in a hammock(best camp chair ever IMO), you can lay down in a hamock. If for some strange reason you don't want to sit or lay down in the hammock(unless I am missing something you can only sit or lay in a tent also) then you can sit anywhere on the ground under your tarp that your heart desires. I am far more comfortable spending prolonged periods in my hammock and under my tarp then I ever was in any of my tents. I can cook while sitting in my hammock, or laying in it for that matter. You hang the hammock at 'chair height' just for this reason. Stove is obviously on the ground under the tarp and not in the hammock. One of my favorite things is breakfast in the hammock, haha, you wake up reach out start up your stove and enjoy your nice morning coffee etc right there without ever having to get out of your sleeping bag.
Also another thought. Being one is elevated in a hammock as opposed to being at ground level in a tent wouldn't you feel the conditions more in a hammock?
You are very correct with this statement. Convection is a killer for hammocks. This is why it is critical to learn how to properly rig a tarp for a hammock. The tarp is your primary defense against wind. Your secondary defense is your quilt or pad setup. A well hung under quilt(most are made of momentum or or wind resistant but breathable material) or a regular sleeping pad in the hammock will insulate your underside from the wind and cold. There is also a new item called a hammock sock that I just recieved that I will be testing new years weekend on my next trip. A hammock sock is literaly a sock or tube of material that goes around the hammock and under/top quilts to provide vet another dead air space and prevent drafts. But I have been getting by just fine without the sock so far, but it will be like a bivy and add 10-15F on average and it only weighs 6.25oz so this is a hugh warmth to weight ratio.
Another question, what does one do to alleviate spindrift issues?
Last thought... Its not really hard to build a wind brake/wall for a tent if need be.
What does one do for a hammock?
You do it extactly the same way. don't forget that you are using a tarp with your hammock. You can easily build a wind brake/wall around the tarp if need be.
I am just thinking here. You are carrying the hammock, line, 2 quilts, tarp, blah blah blah. Thats quite a few steps for shelter from the elements.
Kind of a pain in the rear being my tent goes up in one shot and even if I set it up in a down pour it stays dry on the inside.
Well I assume you are carring your tent, poles, tent inner i think you said, maybe a footprint, your sleeping bag, your sleeping pad etc. That sounds like just about the same amount of items to me. The adjustable webbing is semi permenantly attached to the hammock in cinch buckles. I basically have 3 stuff sacks, one with the hammock and quilts in it, one with my tarp and tarp line in it, and one with a few stakes for the tarp.
I find it very easy to set up my system in a down pour. I set up my tarp and then step under it and hang my hammock, there is a biner on each end of the hammock attached to the adjustable webbing you just reach around the tree and clip it to itself and your done. Just as easy breaking camp in the rain too. Very similar to a tent setup just a little different. I have never once gotten my hammock wet during a set up in the rain.
On my last 2 most recent trips there were very large trees uprooted all over the mountain due to high wind. What does one do if your hammock would be tied off to one of these trees?
Well...you pray and then you grab your ankles and kiss your ass goodbye of course! I have been through quite a few strong storms in my hammock setup thus far, and while I have never been attached to a tree that fell it is certainly a risk. Part of the site selection process for a hammock is tree selection, this is crucial that you know how to identify potential hazards. For one you want to be in a grove of trees and not in an exposed area during high winds. This way your trees have other trees around them to help break the wind. That or use natural barriers to your advantage such as on a hill side etc. You have to know how to select a strong and healthy tree. But even if you pick a perfect tree it could still certainly fall, that's just a risk you have to take. The roof of my house could blow off during high winds too, but I still come home every day.
In heavy wind trees sway.
Grab the dramamine?
Maybe it's because I spent almost 10 years in the Navy, but I can barely even tell the trees are swaying while I am in my hammock. If it's REALLY windy the hammock will usually gently sway just a little bit. You have to remember that the hammock is under alot of tension while you are in it. It doesnt have much slack to sway or otherwise blow around. That or I am oblivious to it because I am an ex sailor. I personally enjoy the slight swaying that I cause my self(I shift my body weight to make the hammock start to rock a little and it goes for 5-10 minutes at a time), like my mama is rocking me to sleep =P.
Lets not forget that you have to check every tree you set under for widow makers. Not so much with a tent being I can set up away from trees.
Then again there is always the chance of my getting slammed by an asteroid. :)
You certainly do have to check for widow makers, that is what I spend the 5-10 minutes of site selection doing. Looking for strong healthy trees without any widow makers. If you set up your tent near or under trees you should be doing the same thing.
Since hammocks are elevated off the gound we will survive the asteroid impact, it's just physics!!!! The shockwave will just make us sway like crazy and being that I am a sailor I will probably sleep right through it. Though some may get sway sickness and puke all over perfect tenting ground.
Also, I can fit my 85L pack, boots, etc in my tent protected from the elements.
So can I if I so choose to put them in my hammock. I can slide the empty pack under my feet in the double layer of my hammock. I also have a shelf in my hammock for the small items. But I usually just leave them on the ground under my hammock, that or put the pack cover on and attach the pack to one of the trees I am hanging from.
Granted, a sleeping bag & a pad is truly needed to be warm in colder temps but how many steps must one perform & how much time does it take to get a hammock set up when you know what is rolling in and you have to get out of it before you get hammered?
5-15 minutes depending on how fast you can find trees. AKA the same as normal.
Then there are you pitching limitations. Last thing I want when on trail is limitations of any type
What kind of limitations? The only one I know of is you cant hang a hammock if there are no trees, But I am surround by trees everywhere I go typically. Trees are the only limitation that I am aware of.
What do you do if you are above treeline and get caught in a storm? Look for trees? I just set up my tent.
I am still considering the hammock for 3 season use. Just not for deep winter. No way, no how.
I think its safe to say that there are pros and cons with either. I just think a hammock carries more cons for deep winter use.
Well, you either head down or you sit down and take it like a man. Haha, ok, I rarely go above treeline. Treeline is not hammock friendly. That being said, when I do go above treeline I do so knowing what the forecast is via a weather radio on my gps. I also plan for bail out routes if need be. Worst comes to worse you find the best natural shelter you can and sit tight till it blows past or you keep on walking to a bail out point. Unless it is a white out, few storms are strong enough to literally stop you from moving. It may be nice to stop and shelter in your shelter of choice, but you don't 'have' to. I can't count how many times while I was in Afghanistan(where the mountains range from 12,000ft to 24,000ft) where a bad storm would be rolling in and we kept on truding through. It sucks, but hey what can ya do.
There are pros and cons for both tents and hammock. Though in all actuality the principles of what you need to have to be comfortable don't really change all that much, or they don't have to at least. Hammocking in winter is not nearly as easy as hammocking in summer, and tenting in winter is far easier than hammocking in winter. But the prices I pay for extreme comfort are worth it to me. Hammocks take knowledge, patience, and a few key skills to make it an enjoyable experience. To learn all you ever wanted to know about hammocks visit www.hammockforums.net
Ok I am done... hope I answered all your questions satisfactorily.