10:40 p.m. on October 31, 2007 (EDT)
If you've not been on Buffalo before, get Tim Ernst's Buffalo trail guide in any good bookstore. Describes every Buffalo area trail (and there are plenty) plus tips to some good off-trail fun. My hike buddy and I have done this several times: Tack together several trails by short bushwhacks, or using short stretches of the forest roads and/or horse trails to make bigger loops than any trailbook describes.
Here's 1 Example (I'll talk fast but it's still gonna be a long post and it will make more sense with Tim's book and your maps @ hand....)
OK: Park at 1 of the stores in Ponca on the upper Buffalo; get a lift or walk 10 mins on pavement to Ponca low water bridge, cross it & follow Buffalo River Trail downstream to next low water bridge; across the bridge you'll see an old barn, house, and gravel road that lead a short distance to Cecil Creek trailhead.
Follow Cecil trail counterclockwise several miles until pops out on the same forest road that runs from the tiny town of Compton to Kyles; turn right (uphill toward Compton) & follow this very steep rough road to top of the mtn, looking for powerline crossing. Parking area under the powerline is the end of a horse trail (Bench Trail), which seems hardly used; follow Bench Trail 3-4 miles upriver to Wild Vic's cabin and junction with Hemmed-In Hollow trail (no river views on the Bench but it's mostly flat, fast and has some historic sites).
Take the beautiful Hemmed-in Hollow trail downhill to river. Too deep to wade here, so play around until you can hitch a crossing with a canoeist; across the river you are almost within sight of the Buffalo River Trail that you began on. Walk straight into the woods until you pick up the Buffalo River Trail and turn right (upriver). This is the same trail you began on...it runs back to Ponca low water bridge. Healthy hikers can do this loop in under 2 days, but take 3 for plenty of playtime.
With the guides & maps you will spot a half-dozen ways to vary even this 1 example. 3 quick examples:
* Halfway around the Cecil trail, jog off trail (see Tim's book) and in 10 minutes you get into the next little watershed, Broadwater Hollow. Broadwater creek is traced by a short trail with many many waterfalls. Follow it upstream to the forest road, then retrace to Cecil trail.
* Or, when the Cecil trail ends @ that steep old road I mentioned, turn left & take the forest road downhill a short distance then pick up another trail that's in Tim's book, go downhill to some old settler cabins and a trail that runs downriver back to the old farmhouse and low water bridge. Cross the river to Buffalo River Trail you began on, and retrace steps back to your car. This is a 1.5 day hike if you get an early start.
* Or, when you follow Hemmed In Hollow trail down to the river, don't wait for that canoe ride. Jog over a few hundred yards to Granny's Cabin (it's in Tim's book) and follow another trail that climbs up up and out to the state Hwy between Ponca and Compton. You can walk to Ponca on hwy (no fun) or hitch a ride back to Ponca (no problem).
Sorry to be so long-winded, got kinda worked up. Excuse me now, I gotta take a hike!