ProBar Old School PB&J Bar



Nuts, nuts and more nuts. OK, technically seeds but…

Rating: rated 4.5 of 5 stars
Source: received it as a sample, freebie, or prize (Seth at Trailspace)


Nuts, nuts and more nuts. OK, technically seeds but still really yummy.


  • Nuts/seeds I have never tried before
  • Healthy ingredients
  • Meal replacer
  • Great nutty, chewy texture w/o tasing like a brownie
  • Vegan, if that's your thing


  • Does not taste/resemble a PB&J sandwich to me
  • Not especally filling for 370 cal

Touted as a meal replacement bar, this offering is a nutrient dense bar with nearly 400 calories per bar. 

After over three decades I still enjoy a good PB&J, unless I am around one of my peanut allergic acquaintances, which seems to be more common for some reason. I was concerned that the PROBAR might mangle their attempt at replicating this staple of my cold lunches and I had low expectations when I unwrapped this bar during lunch.



This bar is evidently 100% vegan which does nothing for this omnivore but may appeal to some. I was pretty much able to understand all the ingredient names (still don’t know what Arabic gum is) but it looked pretty edible. 

Still though this bar is 370 calories in a very small package. I wasn’t overly full after eating it and could see myself eating a lot more food and ending up with a big calorie bill without feeling especially full. 


For better or worse, this looks nothing like a PB&J sandwich.  This is a fruit and nut bar, plain and simple, with very little fruit. If a brown bar crusted with more different kinds of nuts than an alien abductees convention appeals to you you’ll like it. Once I got over the idea that it wasn’t a PB&J in a bag, I was able to enjoy it a lot more. 


No jelly. Yes, I think those are hemp seeds.


Again, nothing like a PB&J. Little/no peanut butter flavor, little to no fruity jam flavor and nothing resembling bread. Mostly nuts and a great figgy/malty-tasting dough mixture. I thought it tasted fantastic. I like the textures of the nuts and their flavors; a little sweet and not too salty. 

I gave a bite to one of my kids and about lost a finger, she loved it too. These are very good-tasting bars even though they don’t, to me, resemble a PB&J in the least. This bar didn’t stand a chance after I tasted it. 


She left me a little after her bite.



I think this bar is a keeper, I’d eat one just about any day. If you want PB&J flavor on the trail make yourself a sandwich and bring it. Just remember to put peanut butter on both slices of bread so the jam doesn’t soak through. If you want a bar that’s got good things in it and also tastes good, this is a good option. 

One caveat: For being nearly 400 calories I didn’t find it as filling as, say, a baked potato with butter which has less than 300 cal. It is possible that you could overeat and end up snoozing under a tree rather than tearing up the crag/trail like you planned, or it might be the perfect way to down some balanced energy in a quick compact package when you can’t afford to stop and cook. Either way give this bar a try.


I agree on the great taste, Sage. I haven't had the PB&J, but the ProBars I've had are very tasty! My son said one was the best bar he's ever had. The high calories are the one big issue. I usually don't need a 350+ calorie bar either. I wish they came in half sizes.

4 years ago

Update. My oldest boy called the one I tried to give him a hippie bar and didn't want to try it. Funny, but frustrating too. He prefers jerky, this week anyway.

4 years ago

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.

ProBar Old School PB&J Bar

previously retailed for:
$3.29 - $28.76

The ProBar Old School PB&J Bar is not available from the stores we monitor. It was last seen July 31, 2013 at

Recently on Trailspace

Meet Vladimir, Bike Tourist of the North and Reviewer of the Month

Seek Outside Unaweep 6300 Review

Good To-Go Granola Review

Trailfoody The Wanderer Review

Marmot Limelight 3P Review

Stanislaus NF