The best ice traction pull-ons I have found so far,…
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: NOK 500 = about $70 at current exchange
The best ice traction pull-ons I have found so far, much tougher than the others. A notch or two shy of crampons in a packable size and weight.
- Tough construction
- Easy on and off
- Solid grip on the worst ice
- How long will they hold up? Time will tell...
The roads, sidewalks, and trails can get seriously icy here in Trondheim, with at least two consequences: an upsurge in emergency room visits (our neighbor actually broke her femur taking her son across the street to the school bus), and brisk sales in all kinds of traction devices (brodder in Norwegian).
The cheapest and most common type have studs set in relatively thin rubber that stretches over the bottom and sides of your shoes. They don't always grip well, and usually the studs falclout or the rubber tears before too long. Yaktrax are better, but they also don't bit very deep and my wife broke a pair in a little more than a year. So when I saw these in one of the outdoor stores, I had to try them despite the price.
Snowline Technical Mountain Gear is A korean company that makes a variety of backpacking and camping gear. Some of it looks quite interesting, but this is the only item I have come across in stores. I don't know how widely these are distributed in the U.S., but I think think they are worth looking out for.
So you get the idea — all-steel traction held to the shoe with a heavy-duty wrap-around and over the toe silicon rubber rand. There are eight triangular points in the forefoot and three on the heel, all about 1 cm (2/5") long. They are not exactly razor sharp but I have found they give a solid grip in both hard ice at temperatures well below freezing and in in wet soft ice at temps above freezing — conditions in which the small studs on my winter running shoes and studded bike tires struggle to get a grip.
I have also used them on an early season snow hike up a nearby hill when they weren't really necessary but they took all the slip out of walking up and downhill in snow and thereby saved a lot of energy. They stay in place with very little slipping or movement on the boot. SO far I have not had any problems with them clogging up with snow.
They come in a mesh-reinforced plastic case small enough to fit in a side or top pocket. With case included they weigh in at 470 grams or just a bit over a pound. Although there may be lighter options, I would consider carrying them on, for example, early summer trips in the Alps or the Sierra where you may run into hard refrozen corn snow in the mornings. If things get at all steep in those kind of conditions, I want a solid grip, and these are lighter and more compact (and with a lower risk of self-injury) than crampons. But I'd want to give them a thorough trial before relying on them for long traverses on steep slopes, especially with any kind of a load.
I bought them last winter and haven't used them all that much, so consider this a preliminary report. I have used them with hiking boots and NNN-BC ski boots. I'll try to report back on durability later, but so far they have help up well and I'm very impressed. I just bought a pair for my wife as a Christmas present — now that's a vote of confidence!