The Big Agnes Fishhook UL 2 is a great choice for…
Source: received for testing via the Trailspace Review Corps (Sample provided by Big Agnes for testing and review)
The Big Agnes Fishhook UL 2 is a great choice for two hikers looking for excellent space-to-weight ratio. At 4 lbs, the tent is even good for the comfort driven solo hiker.
- Superb construction
- Excellent space-to-weight
- Nice color scheme
- Easy set up
- Innovative and easy door system
- Thin floor material
When living the mantra of ultra-light is best, multi-purposing is always better, and the minimalist always prevails, we tend to miscalculate the intangible — comfort and enjoyment. Yes, there is still a place for the comfort driven backpacker when living the trail dream.
As technology improves, the sacrifice between light weight and comfort becomes less significant. The Big Agnes Fish Hook UL 2 zipper-less tent is no real sacrifice. For two hikers the weight-to-space ratio is excellent. At a cavernous 37 sq. ft., it provides ample living space while maintaining a weight ratio of only 2 lbs per hiker. The living space is further enhanced by the ridge pole spreading the top for head room and the steep walls allow more interior space. The dual roof vents provide adequate airflow.
The packed size is a manageable 6 in. x 23 in. according to Big Agnes. I found this to be close to the mark when fully compacted in the stuff sack and all the excess air pushed out. The poles packed in at about 21 inches.
I could easily pack this tent in the middle of my 60L pack with no issues.
Since I am primarily a solo hiker, I had some initial reservations concerning carrying a tent designed for two people that it was more tent than I needed. I got out my 9-year-old MSR Zoid 1 and began comparing the numbers. The reality I found was this:
The Zoid 1 was only ½ lbs. lighter and the space was less than half the BA Fish Hook UL2. To me, this opens up some possibilities. The extra weight of the BA Fish Hook UL2 comes from a modified dome tent design, steep walls, and increased head room which are all added benefits and make up for any increase in weight.
These features make this tent an exceptionally comfortable option. For example, in the hot and sultry Uwharrie National Forest, I found that I had room to stretch out, cool off, and relax. The extra space was a big plus in other ways as well. In the winter, when I pitch the fly and footprint, I will be comfortable in rainy weather by keeping a good margin of space between me and the drippy sides allowing me to stay dry. For comparison, this was always a concern when winter camping using this set up fly only with my MSR Zoid 1 I would find myself always uncomfortably close to the edges when the winter rain was falling.
The Nuts & Bolts:
The Big Agnes Fish Hook UL series tents tout the main feature of being zipperless. I must say that after using the tent, I found the zipperless feature to be very user friendly and convenient. By going zipperless, the hiker can save weight, eliminate annoying zipper noise, and economize on the effort of zipping and unzipping a tent door. I also appreciate that sand and grit in the zipper is no longer an issue. This is a big plus since you do not need to worry about a zipper getting fouled in heavy rain where you are likely to have grit splashing up onto your tent fly.
I admit I had reservations about bug protection. When camping this summer in Uwharrie with an epic mosquito population, I found no issues with any critters getting inside. I have found bug protection to be just as effective without the zipper closure.
Some additional features of the zipper-less design are that the 2 hooks are strategically placed where one can easily match them to a D-ring. Extension flaps ensure foolproof bug protection. The flaps can be draped inside or outside depending on preference.
This is the interior door hook. Note the reinforcement patches and bar tacks with no missing stitches or ragged seams.
The hook pictured here is on the tent body door and hooks into the loop shown at the edge of the picture above it.
I found that the seams on the tent body and fly to be flawless, impeccably sewn, and sealed. I found the tent to be dry and rain worthy.
The floor and footprint material are quite thin. While my initial impression is that this will not be durable, I believe that a little extra care in where you set your tent up (any tent) can go a long way in extending its useful life.
There are 4 pockets sewn into the tent body in each corner and 4 in the roof where you can store a myriad of small items. I especially appreciate the pockets in the roof. In my opinion, Big Agnes has done well here.
The tent weighs in at 3 lbs. 15 oz. with 9 stakes, body, fly and a foot print. The body has one zipper less door on the side.
The fly has a 9 sq. ft. vestibule and the ridge pole helps increase the headroom a bit.
Note the flap at the top of the door effectivley sealing the closure from insects.
The poles are connected via hub at the cross point with the ridge pole attaching on top in a specially designed clip. The fly also attaches with another clip, shown here, it is the black one.
Just how durable this hub is, only time will tell. It appears to be very strong.
The tent is easily pitched. I was able to set up the tent and fly in about 4 minutes solo without complication. Two people could obviously set up a little more easily if not faster. The point is that set up is simple and straight forward. The color coded ends matching the fly and poles to the tent body make set up a snap.
If I had one nitpick, it would be the high nylon panels that blocked the breeze making the tent seem a bit warmer. After spending a night with my wife at Edisto Beach State Park in sultry summer weather, I was wishing I could feel that slight breeze blowing over the top of that nylon panel. If you are in cooler temperatures, the high sides would definitely be a plus since they help block wind.
UPDATE 6/5/2014: I recently used this tent on a 40-mile hike in the Uwharrie National Forest. We had heavy rain on the first two nights. I was very impressed at how well the tent ventilated and how the tent stayed completely dry inside despite the heavy rain. This tent is a winner!
This tent is perfect for the lightweight backpacking pair wishing to maximize the space-to-weight ratio without sacrificing comfort. I highly recommend this tent for two people on the trail.
For the solo hiker I also recommend this tent for the easy overnight. It is comfortable and very spacious. For the winter solo in light weather, I recommend the fast pitch option where you eliminate the tent body reducing your weight down to 3 lbs and still have a spacious sturdy shelter.
This is the Big Agnes Fish Hook UL2 at Edisto Beach State Park.
It is light, roomy, easy to set up, and I got it at…
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $235 with footprint and shipping included.
It is light, roomy, easy to set up, and I got it at an excellent price.
- Easy to set up
- Weight is such that I use it as a HUGE solo tent
- Zipperless aspect takes getting used to, but not really a con
A friend had the solo version, which I liked so much I planned to get one. In checking out the differences between the solo and two-man size, I was willing to carry the extra weight of the larger tent in exchange for the increased roominess.
Setting this tent up is very quick and easy.
Used it in a snowfall in the Sierras in winter and it stood up to the weather like a champ.
With the door being located on the side of the tent instead of the end of the tent, it is easier getting into and out of this tent, which at my age was a main factor in buying this tent.
I love this tent and would not hesitate in buying it again if the need arises.
Does the job in all kinds of weather. I have used…
Source: received it as a personal gift
Does the job in all kinds of weather. I have used this in the snow, in the swamp, and on the trail in wind and rain, and don't forget the sunshine. The neat thing is this tent is lightweight and has no zippers.
- Great protection
- Moisture seems to penetrate rather than shed off
Sets up easy, just remember to have the pole system right side up so you can set the crossbar on top. Easy to stake and pitches taut and tight. Stable in all conditions.
Tends to accumulate moisture rather than repel it, but have never had a leak. Just a hassle to try and wait for it to dry before you pack it up. Vents well with no moisture inside.
Could use a larger vestibule for equipment since room is limited to two man, but long enough to handle a large man lengthwise.
Have only had in use since Christmas, but it has over 40 nights already and seems to hold up well to the use. Has been set up in the Smokies and higher elevations along the AT, not to mention in the Okefenokee Swamp for nearly a week.