Reviews

2

Do not fear the quilt. Unless you're a wild thrasher,…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $369 +

Summary

Do not fear the quilt. Unless you're a wild thrasher, in which case a quilt might actually be good for you. Worked for cynical old me.

Pros

  • Very light
  • Very warm
  • Dries rapidly

Cons

  • As light as it is, I would love it to be a bit more generous in size.

I decided a few months back to get serious about paying off my credit cards, but couldn't help one last splurge before dumping the plastic in the shredder. I was also absolutely sure I didn't want to spend another 2-3 weeks in the Sierra in a less than perfect sleeping bag, or as I was leaning towards, more and more—a quilt. 

Hours of spotty on-line research, following the crowds and what everyone else was buying up—the cottage industry quilts and so on and I finally just went with brand loyalty. I own a few other Brooks Range Mountaineering products and so their quilts got my attention. 

Still, I was really worried about the idea of a quilt and whether or not it would actually do the job. I realized this could be another, almost $400 blunder and as soon UPS got to my doorstep I began to get a bit worried—it weighed so little and even less once I'd carefully removed the Cloak 15 from the box and fluffed it up—it was like shaking out a paper towel. 

I had a few weeks to go before heading out to do the middle section of the Sierra High Route, but after just a few minutes of time under the Cloak 15, on the living room floor, I tossed it in the gear closet and awaited my fate. 

I own two other bags. One a 1972 Trailwise Slimline Chevron, rated somewhere in the low-teens to somewhere in the minus. Made for winter expeditions and not really a great summer Sierra bag. I never ever got cold, but I was often way too hot and tended to just sleep under the bag, quilt-style. It also weighs 5.5 pounds. 

A few years ago in Nepal, I walked into a very nice mountaineering shop and handing over the plastic, bought what I thought would be a very nice, very light minimalist sleeping bag from Millet. It weighs nothing, has a 3/4 zipper and if you've ever seen a butterfly trying to escape from a cocoon, that's pretty much what my nights in that bag became; cold and restless...Warning; if you are in a foreign country and asking questions that they keep answering yes to, you might be in trouble. 

...and so there I was first night out with the Cloak 15, high in the Sierra and in spite of the absolute grandeur of it all, the big thought on my mind and what I was anticipating most that first night was, how good would this Brooks Range Mountaineering Cloak 15 actually be? 

I was not disappointed. I was almost too warm a few nights. I also had this fear that I wouldn't be able to stay under the quilt and that there'd be a bunch of cold spots around the edges, but again, a night and then another proved me wrong. 

I'd only seen one on-line video review and the guy was 6'2" and slightly heavy, I am 6'1" (and not) and think if you're over 6'3" or just really rotund, this isn't the quilt for you. 

20146534090_a1347915d0_z.jpg

A lot or most of the quilts I've seen seem to be just stripped down sleeping bags, with a round foot-box and no zipper. The Cloak series are all flat. The toe box, very wide. The side baffles, generous—it really is a quilt, flat, warm, roomy. 

I also chose the 15 degree with an eye towards spring back-country ski trips, but also, considering the Sierra, I couldn't see spending a lot of money on a quilt only rated to 30 or 45. 

If you're on the fence (or a rock, or cliff . . . no, wait, go back to the fence) about buying a quilt, jump off and give the Brooks Range Cloak series a try. 

Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

Thanks for the review, JMTx13. That is a beautiful shot!


2 years ago
JMTx13

Alicia, Thanks . . . rocks get cold too, ya know ;)


2 years ago

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.

Brooks-Range Cloak 15

previously retailed for:
$277.46

The Brooks-Range Cloak 15 is not available from the stores we monitor. It was last seen August 31, 2017 at CampSaver.com.

Recently on Trailspace

High Country Apps Colorado Rocky Mountain Wildflowers Review

Geigerrig Tactical 1600 Review

Aqua-Bound Sting Ray Carbon Review

Light My Fire Spork Titanium Review

Mt. Chocorua, NH, 15 October 2017

Uwharrie Trail 2017 40 Mile Event