Soft Shell Jackets

Reviewed by Jake W

The Mountain Equipment Echo is an unlined soft shell jacket designed for active pursuits with specific designs for the climber, including articulated arms, a drop hem, helmet-compatible hood, and dual toggle hem. I have found this jacket highly useful for ranges far out of its intended uses—as a protective layer against the sun, a mid-layer in cold winter temps and, of course, as an outer layer in cool temps, especially against wind and abrasion.

I have been testing the Mountain Equipment Echo Hooded Jacket for almost six months now and it has been used from a frigid Canadian January winter to intense Jamaican sun-soaked beaches. It's been used for backpacking, ice climbing, rock climbing, and travelling for a total of who knows how many total days, I wear it so incredibly frequently. I would venture a guess of a least 50 days of activity as well as a bunch of casual uses. It's probably been through the wash six or seven times. FIT  The fit of the Echo is spot on, slim fitting without being restrictive.

Read more: Mountain Equipment Echo Hooded Jacket review (1)

Featured review by T.J.

A very useful "on the move" piece that layers well, cuts some wind while still being breathable, doesn't restrict movement and has a very durable, stretchy face.

I've had the OR Ferrosi Hoody for about four years and it's typically in my pack from Spring to late Fall. It's sort of a hard one to put in to a specific box as far as performance. I think it's jacket that you need to play with a bit, with different layering and conditions, until you find the lane where it works best. There's no additional insulation to this jacket and at first it might seem like it has very limited uses. But you'll soon find that it's the right one to work in your system under a variety of conditions.

Read more: Outdoor Research Ferrosi Hoodie reviews (2)

Featured review by Mike

As the equipment coordinator for a Search and Rescue team I was faced with buying up to 50 "fleece" jackets for my team members. Based on my experiences with Arc'Teryx (see my review of the Alpha SV Jacket), I decided on the Gamma MX. I chose the hooded version for added warmth when a toque just won't do.I have not regretted this purchase, and I continually get feedback from the team members on how much they like this article of clothing. Believe me, when I buy something they don't like they are the first to complain.

Read more: Arc'teryx Gamma MX Hoody reviews (12)

Featured review by Ben McCloskey

I love this jacket. I've been living in it for a few months now. It absolutely blocks the wind, but breathes really well. Fit is outstanding! Best uses would be anything active, really.

Let me start by saying that I've never really liked softshells. They seemed to not really do enough for me, and I'd just end getting rid of them in favor of something else due to their cost. I had also never owned one with a hood. Well, I don't know what got into me, but I tried this one on in REI, and just didn't really want to take it off! Here I am on a backpacking trip a couple weeks ago in the Big Frog Wilderness wearing the ROM Jacket. Fit, Comfort, Layering, and Adjustability I tried it on with just a tee: fit well.

Read more: Marmot ROM Hoody reviews (8)

Featured review by Andrew F.

this is my first soft shell top or bottom, a gift.  as a hard shell lover, i was prepared to be disappointed in how this would perform.  instead, i really like it.  the jacket is new, so it's too early to comment on long term durability.  the workmanship looks good - no loose stitches or frayed edges anywhere.  initially, the zipper was fussy about 1/8 of the way up, right at the bottom of the hand pockets.  that went away after wearing it about a week.  it has two large zippered pockets that open along each side seam, for your hands, and one good-sized zippered pocket at the left chest.  the cuffs aren't elastic but close with a velcro tab.  the hem has a shock cord that tightens by pulling the cord from inside each of the side pockets.

Read more: The North Face Apex Bionic Jacket reviews (18)

Reviewed by Levi_Athle

Montane Extreme Smock I use this smock for hiking and low temperature long distance walking. Key features are: ATHLETIC CUT, DURABILITY, BREATHABILITY. I am 6'6" so the good shape and long arms are handy, the Pertex 6 fabrique is very tough material, abraisan resistant and strengthened under the forearms and elbows, very breathable: i use it with a thin Odlo baselayer, and don't get sweaty at all, neither with backpack. Unlike the coat, the smock has a 4-way ventillation, so when things get hot, just open on the two sides and the cangaroo pocket and the Crossvent system will work fine.

Read more: Montane Extreme Smock review (1)

Reviewed by FromSagetoSnow

After giving up on soft shells I am back to being a fan.

After the last soft shell jacket I was wearing became soaked during an all-day sleet I said never again. People told me, “soft shells are only for light rain or dry snow.”  I thought, So now I need to be able to predict the weather?  Comparing the new Alchemy to those old jackets is like comparing my ‘02 Focus to a new Audi S5. If you remember such things, the MH Alchemy jacket used to be a hoodless soft shell made with Windstopper (aka:Rainsopper) fabric (see previous non-hooded MH Alchemy Jacket).

Read more: Mountain Hardwear Alchemy Hooded Jacket review (1)

Featured review by Matt Wright

Keeping warm and dry when hiking.

Got mine recently and tested it winter walking. Firstly, trust their advice and wear this as a shirt next to your skin. Believe me, it works brilliantly even if it seems counterintuitive. This keeps you lovely and warm without sweating and without creating chilly perspiration. I liken it to the effect the dog must get from his coat with the inner fur and water repellant outer hairs. I carry a light Goretex in my rucksack if the weather becomes ferociously wet. The Buffalo shirt can be easily ventilated via its zips.

Read more: Buffalo Special 6 Shirt reviews (7)

Featured review by Seth Levy

The Black Diamond Dawn Patrol Jacket is a versatile, light-to-midweight softshell that's best for fast-paced activity in cold weather. The Dawn Patrol shows its stuff moving fast above zero and below 40 degrees. Like any softshell, it's not well-suited for pouring rain or frigid cold (there is no hood and very little insulation), but for nearly every aerobic activity I tried in cold weather (running, walking, hiking, snowshoeing, biking, and cross-country skiing), it proved to be a great companion. I would recommend this without hesitation as a general-use garment for aerobic activity of all sorts in cold weather.

Technical Specifications: Weight: 524g/18.8oz MSRP=$249Manufacturer Claim: "This slim soft-shell sacrifices nothing, striking an ideal balance between protection and thermal performance."Fabric:  Schoeller Stretchwoven nylon (260 g/m2, 91% nylon, 9% elastane) with brushed back and NanoSphere Technology Fit This jacket is cut for “athletic” folks. I'm 5”8”, 145 lbs, and the waist on a men's medium felt a bit tight to me. For cross-country skiing, biking and running, the lack of “extra” material and the inherently stretchy nature of the garment meant that it moved with me well.

Read more: Black Diamond Dawn Patrol Jacket reviews (3)

Featured review by James Maddox

As much as I wanted to get the Sky Blue Ray color of this jacket, I couldn't bring myself to wear it everyday. Instead, I chose a more muted option; the Nightshade, and I've gotta say that it works rather well. The hint of blue on the access pockets really sets it off. The fabric is Fortius 2.0, sorry Polartec, seems you've been replaced, but it's OK. Fortius does the job without compromise. I have a Gamma AR as well and you can tell the difference between the two. In comparison, you can't go wrong with any of the Gamma models, but while the SV (discontinued) and AR models would be built solely for warmth and durability, the MX would be built for comparable warmth and flexibility.

Read more: Arc'teryx Gamma MX Jacket reviews (8)