Reviews

2

A quality product, with a somewhat old school/traditional…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $199 on sale

Summary

A quality product, with a somewhat old school/traditional "style", that is made of unusually thick/excellent-quality leather that fits me out of the box pretty much instantly.

Pros

  • Durability of the treated leather
  • Softer leather cuff
  • Near-instant comfort of the box
  • Eyelets are cheap and easily replaced
  • Excellent waterproof treatment so long as the leather isn't abraded

Cons

  • Abraded leather can crack when dried quickly
  • Broke one eyelet (in a year of use)
  • Foot bed is textured fabric = blisters with thin socks

Scarpa is an old-school manufacturer that produced this well-priced boot which works very well almost anywhere. Well-priced does not mean inexpensive should you be on a strict budget...I rarely see these on sale and $250 is a fair, full retail, price for what you get. 

Wet or dry this boot can endure most things and work well for years. Only after the lower leather gets heavily abraded (by scree) did I experience that "wet boot feel". Treat them with mink oil and the issue is almost gone. The durability of the upper leather is not an issue...I believe that the water repellant is surface applied and as the outer (originally shiny) leather gets abraded, the increasingly matt surface begins to hold progressively more water for a longer time.

Best fits a narrow last. Instantly comfortable with very little break-in needed (for my shaped feet at least). Upper cuff is made of compliant and buttery-soft leather, so it is easy on the ankles when the terrain is rough. That feature, alone, makes me want to buy this product again and again.

Sole durability is very good. I experienced no separation between the upper last and the sole bond and I often use these boots on frost-shattered rock or while caving. Slightly slippery sole when the going gets really cold (like below -5° C). The laces will fade, then stretch, and then wear out after heavy use within two years. Plus I broke one upper eyelet that was readily available and repaired by a local cobbler for near pennies (okay, it was $2.50). 

Only after other (more well advertised) brand boots wore out in my boot collection, did I begin to realize the durability of the Scarpas. I would recommend them to anyone. But you may have to hunt around to find a store that stocks them, at least in Canada.

Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

Welcome to Trailspace, A. Podor! Thanks for the helpful review of your Scarpa boots. For what kind of hiking do you use yours? I'd love to see some pictures of your pair in your review too, if you're willing to add some.


2 months ago
Nick Mesarhakis

Never owned any Scarpa pair before but have friends who do. And it's strange that you experienced cracking leather problems and the broken eyelet. It's best if you apply oil more often? Still strange though since my friends do not maintain them propelly if not at all and had no problems whatsoever.


2 months ago
A. Podor

I cracked the eyelet during a difficult rock face descent. It hung on an outcrop sliver and this split the eyelet in half. The eyelet base remained riveted to the leather. No damage to the boot itself.


2 months ago
0

A superbly made, lightweight comfortable walking boot,…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: £110

Summary

A superbly made, lightweight comfortable walking boot, with good support for most hikes and trails and long-distance paths. With 100% waterproofing and excellent traction these make most routes a joy to walk. Thoroughly recommended indeed.

Pros

  • Superb grip
  • Instant comfort
  • 100% waterproof
  • Excellent lacing system and quite light too

Cons

  • Boot flexibility can lead to instep splitting after a year or so

I am now well into my second pair of these boots. The first I purchased about three years ago after a friend recommended Scarpa to me. Straight from the box the boots were extremely comfortable with both a snug fitting and very easy lacing system that leads to confidence on the hills.

The leather is  soft yet supportive. That coupled with an extremely grippable soul makes one positive about descending mountains in even greasy, slippy conditions underfoot. Both pairs which I have worn have never let water in, even in the boggiest of conditions and days of driving rain.

The only downside is that the boots are of a soft, flexible leather that after a year or so can split across the instep. I feel that this is a small price to pay for the many pluses these provide...John.

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.