Skhoop Gretchen Windstopper Mini Skirt

Reviews

6

SKHOOP's Gretchen may draw you in with its good looks,…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Source: received for testing via the Trailspace Review Corps (Sample provided by Skhoop for testing and review)

Summary

SKHOOP's Gretchen may draw you in with its good looks, but it's not a skirt to take lightly. A flattering insulated skirt, the Gretchen provides an extra layer of warmth in the backcountry and incorporates side stretch panels for easy layering and unrestricted movement.

This skirt is worn comfortably hiking, snowshoeing, backcountry nordic skiing, and around town. While I could certainly survive in the backcountry without it, I've found myself bringing it along, unwilling to part with it, on many an outdoor excursion this season.

Pros

  • Windproof
  • Unzips easily to shed layers
  • Stretch panels for ease of movement
  • Flattering fit
  • Insulated

Cons

  • Not water resistant
  • Not an outdoor necessity

Testing Conditions:

I tested the Gretchen Windstopper Mini Skirt from November through February in and around the White Mountains of northern New Hampshire. During this time, I've worn it hiking, snowshoeing, and backcountry nordic skiing, as well as around town and out with friends. Temperatures during this period of time have been variable, ranging from 0-50 degrees Fahrenheit. 

IMG_0884.jpg

Fit and Comfort:

The Gretchen is available in sizes ranging from extra small through extra large and fits true to size. I have a 25" waist and a 35" hip, and the size small fits me well. If you prefer a baggier fit or plan to layer the Gretchen over something more substantial than a pair of leggings or thin soft-shell or hardshell pant, you may want to consider going up a size.

The skirt is available in black, mandarin (shown), and ocean (teal). I love the mandarin color; it's feminine without conjuring images of princesses and unicorns. 

A combination of insulated shell and flexible fabric makes the Gretchen super comfortable out on the trail. The body of the skirt is a polyester shell filled with synthetic insulation sandwiched between a stretch panel on each side. Both panels are fleece-lined, providing a soft, friction-free interior. While the side panels stretch when they need to, they've retained their shape and flexibility over the four months I've spent testing the skirt. 

IMG_0882.jpg IMG_0886.jpg

Side panel exterior (left) and interior (right)

The stretch panels are true to their name. They provide flexibility for unrestricted movement and allow the skirt to be layered comfortably over pants of varying thicknesses. In the pictures below I'm wearing the Gretchen over a pair of leggings (left) and a pair of soft-shell pants (Bergans of Norway Okla Lady Pant) worn over a thin merino base layer (right).

IMG_0870.jpg IMG_0859.jpg

Along the edge of one of the side panels is a two-way zipper. When hiking steep terrain and in need of an exceptionally wide range of motion, I unzip the zipper a few inches from the bottom of the skirt. I've used this feature often and enjoy having the extra space this allows. 

IMG_0906.jpg IMG_0869.jpg

Zipper unzipped a few inches from the bottom of the skirt

The zipper unzips completely, which allows me to easily layer the skirt on and take it off regardless of what I'm wearing on my feet. While I wouldn't have necessarily thought to incorporate this feature before wearing a skirt into the backcountry, I'm glad it occurred to the folks at SKHOOP as I can picture myself precariously balancing on one snowshoe while threading the other through the opening of a skirt...and I imagine this wouldn't end well for me or for the skirt. 

IMG_0883.jpg IMG_0885.jpg

Side panel zipped (top left), unzipped (top right), and on the trail (below)

IMG_0880.jpg

Insulation & Layering:

I began wearing the Gretchen in late autumn before the arrival of snow (temperatures ranging from 30-50 degrees fahrenheit). During that time, the skirt provided a welcome layer of insulation over a pair of leggings. As winter arrived and the temperatures dipped (0-30 degrees), I began wearing the Gretchen over nordic ski pants or soft-shell pants.

When temperatures hovered around 0 degrees, I opted for a merino base layer under my soft-shell pants. For those who have never before donned an insulated skirt (I was one of you just a few months ago), it feels to me as though I'm wearing a vest over my lower half, insulating the core of my lower body so that resources can be dedicated to keeping my extremities warm. 

The insulated shell is windproof, providing extra protection and warmth on windy days. However, as the wind can blow in through the hem of the skirt, I'd suggest also wearing windproof pants during especially cold and windy conditions.

While the Gretchen is advertised as water resistant, wet snow and rain seem to easily permeate the outer shell (see picture below). The skirt's insulation (and likely the layer of pants I wear under it) seem to prevent moisture from seeping in to my skin. However, I wouldn't expect the Gretchen to repel moisture on rainy days or in wet snow conditions. 

IMG_0910.jpg

Moisture seeping into the outer layer

Breathability is really not an issue when wearing a skirt, as the bottom hem is open to the elements. When I begin to feel warm, but am not yet ready to shed a layer, unzipping the bottom zipper a few inches provides extra ventilation. I rarely felt too warm while wearing the skirt (I tend to run cold), but it's nice to know it can be easily removed and stored in my pack if I overheat. 

Versatility:

During the time I've spent testing the Gretchen, I've worn it hiking, snowshoeing, backcountry nordic skiing, to and from the ski resort (layered over a base layer), and around town. I wish I'd been able to wear it alpine ski touring, but the Northeast simply hasn't had the snow this winter to allow for this.

Across each of these activities I've felt comfortable wearing the Gretchen. I never experienced restriction in movement. The skirt has stayed in place without riding up or "spinning" off center. 

IMG_0777.jpg IMG_0911.jpg
The Gretchen does not restrict range of motion

The skirt has a low loft (about 1/4 inch), which contributes to a flattering fit. I'm not one to worry too much about appearances when out on the trail, but as a general rule my lower half prefers to avoid being compared to that of the Michelin Man. The skirt provides an element of femininity in the often testosterone-dominated backcountry. And I have to say there is something about wearing a skirt in the woods that makes me feel tough! I enjoy the freedom of being able to wear it on the trail, around town, or out with friends. 

IMG_0898.jpg IMG_0775.jpg

Wearing the Gretchen skiing (left) and snowshoeing (right).

Functionality:

To an extent the Gretchen is a novelty item. I enjoy wearing it along the trail, but it's not a necessity. For this reason, it could be argued that it's not worth the $169 price tag. As with any purchase, the depth of one's proverbial pockets is certainly a factor to consider. There are less expensive comparables on the market. However, having never before worn a skirt in the backcountry, I'm not able to speak from personal experience as to how the Gretchen stands up to other insulated skirts.

I will admit that if I only purchased gear that was absolutely necessary to surviving in the backcountry there would be many an unoccupied hanger in my closet. And while I like to believe that even the most superfluous items I own have a purpose, ultimately there is some gear I carry with me out of novelty, not necessity. Anyone who's ever worn a GoPro, for example, can likely attest to the fact that there is value in the "for the fun of it" factor. How much value? That's up to the individual, their preferences, and their budget.

In addition to its appeal as a novelty item, the Gretchen incorporates some highly functional features. Many of these have already been discussed—its insulating capacity, wind-resistance, side stretch panels and zipper for unrestricted movement and ease of layering, to name a few. There is also a front pocket which is fairly narrow but deep. It easily holds a set of keys and is just large enough to accommodate my phone (iPhone 6). 

IMG_0875.jpg

Front Pocket

The Gretchen is also lightweight and packable. SKHOOP's product page does not list the actual weight of the skirt and my scale is not sensitive enough to provide an accurate reading. To give some reference, it weighs less than my iPhone (4.55 ounces). As seen in the pictures below, the skirt is quite packable, taking up minimal pack space. 

IMG_0887.jpg IMG_0890.jpg

The Gretchen "packed" beside a 32oz insulated water bottle (for comparison)

IMG_0888.jpg

Durability:

Thus far, the Gretchen has held up to the elements without any signs of wear. It's maintained its shape and the insulation has stayed in place without bunching or gapping. I've machine laundered the skirt a few times in cold water, and it's held up well to washing. It dries on the line. I haven't noticed any odors associated with wear or washing.


IMG_0860.jpg

Overall Impressions:

While the novelty of an insulated skirt may not be of value for everyone, SKHOOP's Gretchen is not just designed for apres ski parties or trips to the grocery store (although it looks good and keeps you warm and comfortable around town). It's designed to fit over a variety of layers and allows for freedom of movement across many outdoor activities. The Gretchen is a balance of lighthearted fun and practicality, both of which are elements I like to carry with me when I'm out on the trail.

Thanks to Trailspace and the folks at SKHOOP for the opportunity to test the Gretchen! 

IMG_0874.jpg

Siltloam

I'm still a little confused as to the "why" this product exists. Does your bum get cold faster than your legs? Did you find that you could get away with less pants insulation by wearing the skirt. Or is it entirely style over function?


2 years ago
Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

Hey Siltloam, I'm not an insulated skirt user (yet), so Kelly can give you far better firsthand info, but beyond the fashion and apres sport aspect, many women do use them as a covering when skiing, snowshoeing, etc. I've even seen women alpine skiing with them. A skirt adds some insulation and mid-region coverage over lighter weight pants/leggings/etc, without a lot of bulk. FYI, I am a fan of running and tennis skirts in certain applications, due to the freedom of movement. I actually want an insulated one for the post-ski experience, so I can get out of my hard or soft shell pants, but not walk around in just my baselayers.


2 years ago
OutdoorKelly

Siltloam- Great questions. In my experience, the skirt functions a bit like a vest. By keeping the core of your lower body warmer the extremities can maintain heat. It could also be a good option on a day when you know the temperatures will be increasing as the day goes on, as you could start off with the skirt layered over a lighter weight pant and then shed the skirt as the temperatures warm. Some may use an insulated skirt purely for style, but there are certainly some functional components to take advantage of.


2 years ago
Siltloam

Thanks to both! That helps.


2 years ago
FromSagetoSnow

Something feminine for women to wear outdoors is a refreshing change. It also solves the "tights are not pants" complaint I hear a lot. This might be on the shopping list for a special person I know. She looks at a lot of outdoor clothing and says, "...but I like men." ;)


2 years ago
Siltloam

Jeff - The outdoors are my place to get away from rules like "tights are not pants" and "no black coats with brown boots" rules and to get away from some of the people who live by those rules.


2 years ago
OutdoorKelly

Well, to each their own I suppose. Jeff, I hope your lady friend enjoys the skirt as much as I have! Something with some feminine flare that also keeps me warm is a hot commodity in my book :)


2 years ago
Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

So, I was reading my "Ultra Running" magazine last night and there was an article on training in cold weather and Nikki Kimball (a top ultra runner) listed her cold weather clothing and ended with "...and most importantly my down skirt. It sounds silly, but the down skirt is comfortable and keeps my butt and lower core toasty in the coldest conditions I've found in Montana."


2 years ago
Siltloam

Neat!


2 years ago

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.