Asolo Piuma

2 reviews
5-star:   0
4-star:   2
3-star:   0
2-star:   0
1-star:   0

Reviews

7

The Asolo Piuma is a light, articulate mid-height…

Rating: rated 4.5 of 5 stars
Source: received for testing via the Trailspace Review Corps (Sample provided by Asolo for testing and review)

Summary

The Asolo Piuma is a light, articulate mid-height boot well suited to hiking, backpacking, and general outdoors use. Despite some minor issues with traction, I'd recommend it to any hiker or backpacker it fits. This is the closest thing to an "all purpose" boot I've encountered.

Pros

  • Unique, “articulate” construction.
  • Lightweight
  • Breathable body
  • Fits this tester well.
  • Lacing structure prevents slipping.
  • No break-in required.

Cons

  • Slightly “iffy” traction?

Fit:

I've got a very neutral, average foot: Average arch, average volume, average elongation, etc. My stride is very neutral and balanced too. Though I measure a 10, I prefer a 10.5 in most shoes to accommodate a thicker sock and some swelling that typically happens after 10 or more miles.

Asolo didn't take my word for it though. In order to ensure that I was testing the shoe — and not the fit — their representative made the journey to my office (an hour's drive!) and fit the shoe to me in person. I agreed to meet him in a public market near my home and asked how I'd find him. He replied: “I'll be the guy holding the Brannock device!”
Asolo-Boot-Fit1.jpg

My first public foot-measuring experience, courtesy of Henry Barber at Asolo.

After a very thorough measuring (I've sold shoes for years, and this measurement was more thorough than I typically gave) and a more thorough interrogation, I was issued my shoes. They fit very well out of the box, but just to be sure I wore them around the house for a few days, and didn't notice any problems. The mid-height ankle wraps smoothly around my ankle, there is no bunching in the tongue, the arch is well-placed, a perfect fit!

Asolo-Boot-Fit-2.jpg

Asolo's Henry Barber took a solid 10 minutes to work through a number of calculations to determine the ideal fit.

The Asolo Piuma has a unique shape, much closer to a climbing shoe than a traditional hiking boot. The toes are noticeably narrower, and the entire shoe curves toward the big toe slightly.


2013-11-09-12-47-30.jpg
The Piuma in its natural habitat, right out of the box!

My first vigorous hike on a local trail showed the boot needs little break-in. It's supple, flexible and nimble out of the box. A fast 5-mile hike over marshy ground, rock staircases, packed dirt and roots proved that this boot requires almost no break-in.


2013-11-09-12-37-43.jpg
A great first hike. Showing the curved rand and the articulate toe.

Support:

This boot is minimally to moderately supportive. I don't rely on my boots to prevent ankle rolls, but if you do, I wouldn't rely exclusively on this boot. To be fair, this boot doesn't claim to provide the sort of prosthetic ankle support some people like. Structurally, the top is light and flexible, allowing my tendons to move freely and making me feel as footloose as a dancer, rather than feeling like I'm wearing “moon boots.” I prefer my boots this way. If you're looking for a heavy, rigid boot, this isn't the boot for you. If you like a lighter boot, stop reading and try this one on!

Water Resistance:

The Piuma isn't designed to be water resistant, though it does resist water better than I would have thought for a mesh boot. A light rain took more than an hour to penetrate. My foot stayed dry hiking for a few hours on a packed, snowy trail, and brief exposures to icy mud didn't seep in. Stepping into a deep puddle clearly shows this is a mesh boot, though!

Traction:

This boot has decent traction. It grabs compact dirt, rough rock and steep slopes well. However, on wet rocks, the traction fell a bit short of what I expected. The lugs are of moderate depth, and the tread texture is moderate overall, so this boot does not appear designed to offer “extreme” traction. Additionally, the slope I tested them on was a veritable slip-and slide of wet leaves, ice and river stones. Everyone I hiked with fell at lest once.


2013-11-10-13-01-41.jpg
Slippery rocks alert! I did a little slip-and-sliding on the iced over rocks and leaves on a local mountain.

Temp Control:

This boot shines as a warm weather boot. On a steamy July backpack, my sweaty feet dried INSIDE of these boots within an hour. On regular fast hikes on a rail-trail, these boots dissipated sweat rapidly. In cold weather, they offer little in the way of insulation, but for those of us with perpetually, hot, sweaty feet (ahem.) in moderate climates, these would serve as a reasonable year-round boot. After a 2 hour hike at 30 degrees, my feet felt cold, and I wanted a heavier boot, but I don't think I would have needed a heavier boot.


Pleasant-Mountain.jpg
Feet felt cold, but not too cold!

Ease of Use

The Piuma is easy to put on and lace up. The tongue is well-anchored, and doesn't need to be “set” in order to prevent bunching. The lace eyelets and laces are well designed, sos they snug up quickly and don't come untied easily.

Construction & Durability:

During a year-long test of these boots, and very regular use, they show little signs of wear on the tread, uppers, laces or footbed. They hold up very well for a modern fabric boot in general, and exceptionally well considering how light they are.

2013-11-09-13-06-45.jpg
Still kickin! These boots have proven durable.

Conditions: Where, when, and how long have you used this gear?

  • 5-mile hike in 30-degree dry weather in southern Maine.
  • 6-mile hike in 35-degree wet, snow weather in central Maine.
  • 25-mile backpack in 80 degree weather in Western Maine.
  • 6+ months weekly 5-mile walks on an urban rail-trail.


2013-11-10-13-02-52.jpg
Testing the Asolo Piuma on a freezing day at a local peak.

Conclusion:

Years ago, I made the switch from heavy, leather boots to lighter fabric boots, and finally running shoes for nearly all of my hiking and backpacking needs. I haven't worn a higher-ankle boot in some time.

The Asolo Piuma has really opened my eyes to the possibilities of mid-height boots by incorporating many of the positive features of boots, while retaining the lightness and nimble, articulate feel of a much lighter running shoe.

The unconventional last shape works well for me. If it works well for you, you may have found a boot that will accommodate the vast majority of your hiking and backpacking needs. 

Alicia TRAILSPACE STAFF

Thanks, Seth!


28 days ago
G00SE MODERATOR

So are you going back to a mid-hiker or sticking with running shoes after this testing? I've been toying with the idea of switching from my Patagonia Drifters to a trail running shoe.


25 days ago
KiwiKlimber

I've had my eye on these since L.Dog reviewed them 7 months ago. Next time I need boots, these are atop my list to try on. Thanks Seth.


25 days ago
Seth Levy TRAILSPACE STAFF

I'll stick with my cheap running shoes for most summer backpacking, but these are now part of my regular quiver of footwear.


25 days ago
Seth Levy TRAILSPACE STAFF

I just went for a 16 mile showshoe with another brand of high-top boot. OMG - serious tendon issues! In retrospect this makes this boot even cooler.


18 days ago
Lah

Nice review Seth! I love broadening my horizons in testing gear that I might not normally use but shoes (namely boots) are the one area I have to defer to others. I've de-evolved from boots to trail runners, to running shoes and now to minimalists (and no socks!) over the course of 15 years and just can't see myself going back in the opposite direction. Living in the same pair of minimalist shoes for the past 3 years, I think my feet would revolt in anything else. A lot has to do with the special conditions found in Florida (mud, wet, but not freezing). I will have to give serious consideration if and when I go back to hiking in rocky and possibly snowy terrain...sounds like these boots might be a good option. Thanks for sharing.


13 days ago
5

A light, flexable, breathable, welcome departure from…

Rating: rated 4.5 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $189.50

Summary

A light, flexable, breathable, welcome departure from Asolo's traditional offering, with a wide toe box and well supported heel. May be perfect for light backpacking, dry summer hikes, or long-distance hikes where a quick-drying boot is desired.

Pros

  • Not waterproof
  • Fast drying
  • Asolo's new "Natural Shape"

Cons

  • Not waterproof
  • No cushioning in footbed


DSCF2367-1.jpg

Background:

I’ve hiked 1,318 miles of the AT, and innumerable day hikes over the last couple of years, mostly wearing Merrell Moab trail runners, and Salomon Fastpackers. The Fastpackers are high-top, Gortex-lined boots that are really like high-top trail-runners. They never fit my heel very well, and I kept trying different lacing techniques to lock them in.

The Moabs are very comfortable, and fit me well, though I would invariably get a glister in my little toe, calluses in the sides of my heal, and sometimes blisters under the calluses. I also experienced tendon pain around my heal and ankle. And I twisted my ankle really badly three miles into last year’s section.

Now, I’m not blaming the boots for all those issues. I am nigh unto 60, and often start hiking without the benefit of a rigorous training regimen. I consider myself a lightweight backpacker, generally carrying 24 lbs with food and water. Whether a high-top hiking book actually provides meaningful ankle support is controversial, and I tend to subscribe to the idea that feet need to work naturally for balance and to make sure the rest of the skeleton works as it’s supposed to.

I also have decided that for me, “waterproof’ boots are not very useful on long-distance hikes in the Appalachians.  When they get wet, they stay wet, and that sets up all kinds of foot problems.  Better to have a boot that dries quickly. Imho, hyoh, etc …

I hiked into Outdoor Trails outfitter in Daleville, Virginia, last year with a pair of Moabs that were ready for the trash bin.  They had a great selection of hiking shoes, and they indulged me in trying on all kinds … Till I walked out with a new pair of Moabs …  

DSCF2362-1.jpg

A New Kind of Asolo - In the process, I saw these new Asolos, and was intrigued. They weren’t like any Asolos I’d seen before. Asolo is an Italian company, tho the Piumas are made in Romania, and their boots are well known and respected in the hiking community.  Typical Asolos are sturdy, medium-to-heavyweight boots with a narrow fit.  These Piumas were light, flexible, and had a wide toe box. And they cupped my skinny heels too! I almost bought them then and there. But you know, better the devil I knew …

But when I got home, I started researching the Piumas. Asolo calls their basic design a “Natural shape,” “Light Hikers.” They tout a natural shaped footbed and last, that together are designed to mirror the shape of the foot, cradling and supporting it. A flexible sole and wide toe box is designed to allow the foot to move naturally.

DSCF2365-1.jpg

The uppers are constructed of a water-resistant suede and nylon mesh.  a velveteen lining is designed to wick away moisture. Classic lacing with really nice, metal hooks and eyes, padded cuffs for the ankles, gusseted tongue, and hard rubber toe fenders. They are not waterproof, and reviewers said they are fast drying.

DSCF2363-1.jpg

The outsole was developed in conjunction with Vibram to support their new “Natural Shape” fit. They claim the multi-layer design reduces stress on the main points of impact, and that its structured shape offers support and improves foot control on the sides and the back. The bottom sports self-cleaning lugs, designed for optimum performance on varying types of terrain.

I was intrigued enough to push the button.

DSCF2366-1.jpg

My limited Experience:

The fit on my feet is astounding. The wide toe box allows my toes to spread, without excessive movement, and my heal is cupped perfectly, and without any slippage. I’ve been wearing them on daily walks on sidewalks, and day hikes in trails around Western Michigan. I love the way they seem to roll from heel strike to push off, while still allowing my foot to flex naturally. 

The footbed itself does not seem to have any cushioning, tho the outsole does seem to do its job in reducing shock. I have been wearing well-cushioned hiking socks, and they’ve been comfortable. The uppers do feel supportive. No blisters or soft tissue injuries, but I haven’t worn them with a 25 lb pack in the mountains yet either.  I’ll get back to you on how the soles grip in that environment.

I’m kinda disinclined to put any footbeds in them, cause I want to give that “Natural Shape” the benefit of a good trial. But I might put a pair in my bounce box …

The mesh in the uppers, definately lets them breath.  I could feel a breeze pushing thru.  Nice on a hot day. Probably not the best boot for a cold wx hike ...

Piuma is Italian for Plume, by which I assume they mean feather, So, of course, I had to put them on my scale, and they came out to 16.75 ozs ea. For comparison, My Moab mid-heights with original footbeds are 16.51 ozs ea. Light as a feather is all relative, eh? [Shrug]

I’m thinking these are going to be great for hiking and light backpacking in summer and shoulder seasons.

G00SE MODERATOR

Okay, you've got my attention with these. Let me know how they work long term--when I head off on the AT someday, it will be with a 25lb pack.


8 months ago
Bill "L.Dog" Garlinghouse

I'll be back to this review not later than August!


8 months ago
Patman

Same here Bill, good review and thanks for the heads-up


8 months ago
Ashleigh MODERATOR

Great job, Bill. Thanks for the helpful pictures!


8 months ago
KiwiKlimber

Nice review! Those babies look nice. I am about a year-and-a-half into a pair of Asolo Sunset casual hiking shoes, which I really like. They have some of the same features as your Piuma's, most notably the water-resistant suede and mesh, which I find is the perfect balance of keeping your feet dry from both the inside and outside. If I were to buy a new pair of high-top boots today, these would probably be the ones. However, one issue I have had though is the Vibram outsoles is that they are wearing out at very quick pace compared to other shoes I own and use comparably. Of course, you have a different Vibram outsole, but I would be curious if you notice this quick wearing in the future.


8 months ago
Bill "L.Dog" Garlinghouse

Thanks, KK. I'm planning on 867 miles this summer. That oughta provide a datapoint on outsole life!


8 months ago