Katadyn Base Camp
Price Paid: $60
I have used this filter on outings with our Boy Scout troop where the younger boys don't quite have the patience for pumping and where we have a need for lots of water. The filter performs reliably. I agree it's somewhat slow - about 1l/min, but given that you don't have to do much to operate it, it's very convenient. Just hang it up from a tree at base camp, fill it with unpurified water, and let it go. The boys can filter gallons of water while they're doing other things like making dinner or playing cards.
You definitely would not want to use this mid-hike waiting at the river bank for refills. This filter is not the correct filter for that purpose - use your pump. I am satisfied that the specifications for the filter are correct - 1 l/min and a filter life of about 200 gallons.
A few pointers:
* Be sure your water is mostly clean of silt and debris since it is not possible to backflush the filter.
* Fill the filter from a collapsible bucket or other vessel instead of trying to use the filter bag itself to retrieve water from your source.
* Hang the filter as high as possible (6ft) and collect purified water from as low as possible below the filter to maximize the water pressure through the filter.
* If the flow rate starts to slow down, put a liter of clean water in the bag, shake it around and dump it out to rinse the filter and pre filter from silt and debris.
Another positive about this filter is that it uses the Katadyn Hiker Pro cartridge, so it's easy to find a replacement.
Price Paid: unknown
We just got back from a BWCA trip with this filter. Our group of 9 used this exclusively for 4 days (with the exception of the last water bottle fill for the group). We used approximately 25 gallons over the time, and had great water flow for all but the last 2 or so gallons. We filled the bag from the middle of the (clear) lake and we were careful to keep the prefilter clear, and we allowed the water to fill a water bag (5 gal) so that we would make sure we did not spill the water and we could let it fill with us not present.
I'd recommend the product as long as there was also a backup plan for the group. Having clean water was very nice, and not having to kill ourselves to do it was very very nice. The bag did get warm when in the sun, which could cause bugs to grow.
We did carry a cleanable ceramic unit as well to make sure that if things went badly with this one that we would not be stuck boiling water.
Price Paid: $65
I bought this filter primarily for use on Scout trips to make it easier to filter large quantities of water. It works OK and since our water sources are usually quite clean we haven't experienced the dramatically reduced flows other have.
However I still think there are some flaws - the flow rate is still quite slow and I'm surprised there isn't any provision for a clean bag (add on extra) or at least a clean bag connector (e.g. for hydration packs) - to allow for true unattended operation.
I have modified mine to be able to connect to up to 3 hydration packs with quick connect connectors and this simple change makes the utility much higher.
Another issue is the difficulty hanging the system - with the buckle in the center of the handle its difficult to hang and several times the buckle has come undone leading to a real drenching. It is also very heavy to hang when full - so its difficult to hang high without a rope/pulley system - especially for my Scouts.
I have also experimented using the same filter in a container below the bag and raising the bag much higher for more head - this gives much much higher flow rates - so the filter in bag seems quite a compromise for flow rate - though it allows a much simpler design.
I find filling the bag from a creek is quite easy - except for the requirement to keep the clean tube out of the dirty water - it seems Scouts just aren't capable of doing this reliably - which is also a common issue for pump filters. This is unfortunate - carrying an extra remote fill bucket is extra weight.
I do also think that while the dirty bag is extremely robust - really great for Scout use - its probably too heavy duty for most small group users - its heavy and difficult to pack down small.
Conclusion - The filter works but it seems a real compromise - there are some simple things that can make it much better...
Price Paid: $60
Used on a five-day trip on the Green River in Utah. Brought a bucket to "settle" water overnight, and then used a cup to ladle the clearer, top water into the Base Camp.
Worked fine for the first five gallons; after that, was a slow drip. Overnight, we would get one liter of water. Cleaned the pre-filter over and over, and had to use precious filtered water (of which we had so little) to clean out bag and pre-filter.
Thankfully, I had a Sweetwater Guardian and water purification tablets, otherwise we would have been screwed. 100 degree days, exhausting hikes up side canyons -- and not a drop to drink.
Price Paid: $53.96
Have used one of these for four years — approximately 60 person days, filtering about 2 gal. per person per day. That equals roughly 120 gallons.
The filter got quite slow on the last couple of gal. but improved somewhat after cleaning the pre-filter. Hanging the bag as high as possible does make a big difference in flow rate. Have ordered a new cartridge.
It sure beats pumping, although I always have my pump filter as a backup. On our last trip I discovered that the large plastic coffee containers from Maxwell House and (I think) Folgers are just big enough to hold the Base Camp unit and make a very good water scoop.
Price Paid: $59
I bought one of these for a trip to the Buffalo River and it worked great. Fill it up and let it go. We probably filtered 20 gallons of water with no problems.
One potential fix for the problems people have noticed about it not working at first. I experienced the same issue when I first hooked it up to test. Nothing came out. I gave the bag a slight squeeze and voila...the water flowed. From then on, it worked well.
Price Paid: $60
We used this system on a ten-day, May canoe trip on the Green River in Utah. Eight people relied on the Base Camp, with a small ceramic filter as a back-up. The Green is a very muddy river. We began filtering fairly clear looking spring water, but soon had to filter some settled river water.
The filter started out really well, but quickly flow rates were reduced to a fast drip, then a slow drip, then barely anything at all. We changed filters and resolved to filter only clear water.
We augmented river water clairification using alum, which really helped. The filter still slowed significantly within about 20 gallons. The 200 gallon and 0.5L/min rates, quoted by the sales people, are very optimistic. Rather than a pleated paper filter, a field maintainable filter (perhaps ceramic) may be an improvement to the longevity system. The Base Camp filter is a great concept and still beats pump filters for a larger group.
Price Paid: $64.99
good system. Much easier than pumping. Our Boy Scout troop packed into the Ozarks for 4 days. Fairly clean running water source. We were quickly and well supplied for the entire trip. Filtered approximately 60-70 gals... no problems. Great flow.
Next trip was the Kisatchi area in Louisiana. Same filter. Water quality from the bayou was not nearly as good. Only filled the unit 2 times when it slowed to a trickle. Removed filter and cleaned with filtered water. helped for about three gallons.
Unit may be able to use a ceramic upgrade which could be cleaned easier and prolong life. The cleaner the source the longer the filter lasts. Cleaning the current filter will only prolong the service life about 1 refill.
Price Paid: $65.99
Spend your money on a second, cleanable, pump filter and you'll spend less time pumping than messing around with this bag of water. By the end the second fill of the bag, the filter quit almost completely. With clear clean BWCA water, filled from a boat in the middle of the lake, I expect much more for my money. Cleaning the filter as instructed netted 2 liters per day!!!
Price Paid: $69.65
I have used this for 2 full seasons of hiking and random other times, it really beats pumping.
If you put dirty water in it will clog, but just filter water going in w/ hanky or skim the water off the top to get the cleanest. Also Katadyn advises fiilng w/ another vessel and letting the water settle this really helps.
With the lid from my MSR dromedary bag in place of the filter it makes a great shower.
Many many trips and large groups this thing has won the hearts of all who have had the pleasure of using it. Katadyn could actually make this bag bigger/longer maybe, that would be an improvement but it would be heavy.
No more pumping for me.
Price Paid: $50
Love my Base Camp gravity filter. Only wish it were a little more compact. They need a smaller one.
Price Paid: $59
The first fill of the bag was fine. The filter was about as fast as pumping with a Pur Hiker. However, by the third fill it was down to a slow drip. Even after taking the filter apart and out into the lake it was very slow.
At home I again took it apart and held it under the faucet to rinse any possible silt away. No luck. The water I used was pre-filtered through a hankie and was reasonably clean. I took the filter back to REI.
Price Paid: $49
Our group of 10 took a 7-day trip to the Boundary Waters canoe area and used the CERAMIC drip water filter for pristine water. Please note that there are two Katadyn filters that look identical with the blue bag. The best one is the ceramic filter which can be cleaned off for a total of 2000 gallons. The other blue bag camp filter has a polyester filter which is only good for 200 so BUYER BEWARE.
A score of "5" for the ceramic!
Price Paid: $59.95
Wonderfull water filter. We used the filter on a 6-day 4-person boundary waters canoe trip. The filter gave us plenty of good clean drinking water without the fuss of a pump system. Gravity did the work while we fished. The filter did slow down after about 20 gallons of lake water purification. I suggest a spare filter cartridge for longer trips or more people. We did rinse the filter in clean water when we returned home and it did seem improve the speed of the filter once again.
Price Paid: $81
A group of us take annual trips to portage accessible lakes in the Canadian north and have used a number of different water 'cleaning' methods from water purification tablets to hand held micro-filter pumps.
The idea of a system that allows bulk filtration (the bag) and instant use (tablets require 4 hrs of set time) was quite appealing. The instructions for the Katadyn Base Camp require that you prefilter approximately 2 liters of water to clean the filter of carbon dust that has settled in the filter. This is a normal procedure for any carbon based filtering system.
The assembly of the system components is straight forward and uncomplicated. However, the bag did not come close to filtering the water in the advertised time frame. The water was left in the bag overnight and less than a third of the water had filtered out. I was certain that I must have left a protective wrapper on the cartridge filter yet upon inspection found that this was not the case.
I checked on-line and found many favorable reviews of the product and a scattering of ones such as mine. My conclusion is that there must, at the very least, be an irregular quality issue with the product. It cannot, in my estimation, be trusted to deliver a safe and reliable source of drinking water.
Price Paid: $88
I bought this with the intention of using it for group trips, but I tried it out at home and couldn't get it to filter anything. Both myself and a fellow experienced backpacker, that have used 2-3 other water filters before - couldn't get this thing to filter anything.
Based on the other reviews, it seems this product has some issues if most work but some don't.