Specs

men's
Weight 410 g (8.5 UK)

Reviews

A very impressive shoe with a design unlike any other…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Source: received for testing via the Trailspace Review Corps (Sample provided by Arc'teryx for testing and review)

Summary

A very impressive shoe with a design unlike any other shoe I have used previously because of the unique inner and outer construction. I would highly recommend this shoe for anyone looking for a durable, light, and comfortable approach/hiking shoe.

Pros

  • Adaptive liner
  • Durable outer
  • Well constructed

Cons

  • Liner is not removable

I had the opportunity to test the Arc'teryx Acrux FL (originally Alpha FL) hiking/approach shoe during the winter of 2014-2015 in the White Mountains region of New Hampshire.

IMG_0235.jpg

Fit and Comfort:

Over the years I have purchased a variety of footwear. These have ranged from sandals to ski boots, running shoes to heavy weight backpacking boots. The majority of the time I have found that I land comfortably in an off the shelf regular width men's size 10 with the rare 9.5 thrown in to keep things exciting. With that being said, it is always a risk when trying out a new brand to see where their sizing falls into the mix.

When I first took the Acrux FL out of the box I was skeptical that it would fit my foot and be at all comfortable. The inner liner appeared to be too tight and the stiff outer gave me pause since it did not give the impression that it was very flexible.

However, once I put them on my feet the previous concerns were eliminated. I found that the inner liner surrounded my foot in a custom feel almost immediately. While the liner is too snug for a bulky thick sock, my foot fits well while wearing a range of sock thicknesses from light weight summer to mid-weight wool socks. The majority of my usage has been paired with mid-weight wool socks due to the temperatures during the testing period.


IMG_0222.jpg
The outer shell proved to be forgiving and easy to break in and I felt comfortable taking them on trips soon after I received them.


IMG_0229.jpg
The lacing pattern extends from the toe box to the ankle cuff allowing for many levels of refinement. This lacing pattern gives the Acrux FL more of an approach shoe fit without being too restrictive.


IMG_0234.jpg
The inner liner is a single piece that does not contain a tongue. This allowed for the cuff to fit snugly around my entire ankle helping keep snow and debris from entering the shoe. Given that this is a low-profile shoe, I would say it performed at expectation in regards to keeping out snow.

IMG_0230.jpg

The only thing I did not like about the Acrux FL was that the liner was not removable. Based on my research of the other models from this line, it appears that the FL series is the only one with a non-removable liner. Two issues crop up with the fixed liner.

First, is that the shoes require a longer dry time. The second issue is more of a limitation in potential use. Arc'teryx sells a high-cuff liner that fits inside of its other models. With that liner, I would have felt much more comfortable in snowy conditions.

While the liner is not removable, the foot bed insole is removable which allows for the use of orthotic inserts.

Support:

The Acrux FL is a low cut approach/hiking shoe and does not extend above the ankle and therefore does not provide support above the cuff. However, the construction of the out-sole and mid-sole create a very supportive and stable structure which allowed for sure footed strides. The design of the sole also provided cushion with out a feeling of extra padding under the foot.

Water Resistance:

The single piece outer is extremely water resistant and prevents water from entering the shoe. There are various levels of the Acrux FL series and the version I tested did not have the Gore-tex liner. With that being said, the liner on the Acrux FL is fairly water resistant. It kept my feet dry from standing snow and shed light water well. It will be interesting to see how this shoe performs during warmer weather when conditions will lead to more exposure to running and falling water.

Traction:

The out-sole is well designed to handle a variety of terrain and conditions. I felt confident on ice, snow, and dirt. While I was not able to test the traction on rock scrambles due to the conditions during the testing window, I have had approach shoes in the past with similar Vibram sole construction and those have always performed well.

Even though I don't want to see the snow go away just yet I do look forward to hopefully having the opportunity to test the tread pattern on the granite trails of the higher peaks in the Whites this summer.


IMG_0232.jpg

Temperature Control:

I tested these shoes during the winter in New England and found that when paired with a mid-weight wool sock my feet stayed warm and dry. I would not advise using these for long extended outings during cold weather since I feel that that would be beyond the bounds of these shoes. However, they perform well day-after-day for shorter outings in colder temperatures above 20 degrees.

One question that remains is how well this shoe will wick sweat from my feet during the warmer summer months. If I am able to continue testing I will provide an update.

Features:

There are two features which set this shoe apart from any other approach/hiking shoe I have worn. First, is the inner liner, and second is the outer shell.

Arc'teryx claims the inner liner has an “Adaptive Fit” and I found this claim to be accurate. The stretch material used in the liner's construction wrapped perfectly around my foot and with no seams, I had no areas that created pressure or discomfort.

The upper is what really impressed me about this shoe. As I mentioned previously, I was skeptical of how well the upper would break in. Out of the box it is stiff and uncomfortable looking. However, once the shoe is on and moving, the upper proves to be supple and conforming. I was able to review some materials provided by Arc'teryx which describe the construction as a polyurethane coated nylon textile which is woven, layered, and heat set to create a smooth single piece construction that does not contain seams. The outer shell stands up well against ice and snow as well as dirt, salt, and water.

Construction & Durability:

Arc'teryx did a wonderful job constructing this shoe. The outer shell is extremely durable and has held up well over the testing period. I am looking forward to seeing how they perform against the granite trails this summer, but from what I have seen so far I am fairly confident they will work well.

The inner liner has also held up well over use. The stitching is well intact and I have not noticed any internal wear in the foot bed. This is going to be an area I pay close attention to over time as my feet have a tendency to be rough on shoes and I find that the areas under the ball of my foot and my heel become worn quicker than the rest of the shoe.

Conditions:

I tested this shoe during the winter of 2014-2015 in the White Mountains of New Hampshire. One may not feel that a low cut approach shoe would be adequate during this time period, but I found that the Acrux FL performed above expectation.

Paired with a mid-weight wool sock I felt comfortable taking this shoe out on hiking and snowshoeing trips in temperatures down to around 20 degrees on trails with between 6 and 10 inches of fresh snow.

Because the shoe has a low-cut profile, I found that it was best to wear a gaiter if I was going to encounter snow. This was simply a way of adding an extra layer of protection from snow building up around my ankles.


IMG_0225.jpg

IMG_0227.jpg

IMG_0226.jpg
The outer shell held up well against snowshoes and did not show any signs of wear and tear.

Overall Summary:

I was very impressed by the Acrux FL shoe by Arc'teryx. The design is unlike any shoe I have used previously and I found it to be well thought out, designed, and constructed. The Acrux FL exceeded my expectations by holding up well against the New England winter conditions.

I would highly recommend this shoe for anyone looking for a durable, light, and comfortable approach/hiking shoe.

Ashleigh

Great review, Jim! I am excited to see that Arc'teryx has started making shoes!


5 years ago
Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Great review, Jim! I'm glad to hear these worked so well for you so far. One thing I was wondering is, how heavy are these?


5 years ago
KiwiKlimber

That has to be one of the baddest looking approach shoes I've seen. $190 isn't cheap, but it sounds like they are worth the price. Nice review!


5 years ago
Jake W

I agree with kiwi. $190 is a lot for a low cut shoe, I'd definitely be considering that as a con. That said, I'll probably be looking into these when they become publicly available. Great review Jim.


5 years ago
G00SE

Very nice review. I'm suprised you could snowshoe in them!


5 years ago
KiwiKlimber

I'll be interested to see the life of these shoes, especially the liner's life. I'd hate to see the outer remain in great shape while the liner wore out, thus causing them unserviceable. I hope this will not be the case for you, Jim51111.


5 years ago
FromSagetoSnow

Since they are an approach shoe, did you scramble/climb in them any? Are they grippy on rock?


5 years ago
Seth Levy NONPROFIT REP FORMER STAFF

Thanks for your review Jim. I was super curious about these!


5 years ago
Jim51111

Thanks everyone. These were really nice to test out.


5 years ago
Jim51111

@alicia, they come in just under a pound so you don't even notice them on your feet. @G00SE, I was really surprised as well but they did great. @kiwiklimber, I'm going to be paying close attention to the inner liner of these for that exact reason. If they had the removable liner I would be less concerned but this model does not. @Jeff, there was snow and ice on all the rocks during this testing period but I have a number of trails picked out for once everything melts and will post additional pictures and updates then.


5 years ago
Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Thanks, Jim!


5 years ago
Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Update: The new name of this shoe is the Acrux FL. I've edited the page and Jim's review above to reflect that.


5 years ago
Craig Houdeshell

Expensive for what they are.


5 years ago
David Link

These are now on the market for sale. I am very interested in these, but have a few fitting problems. My left foot is a very comfortable size 14, but my right foot is slightly bigger, and always a little tight. How did the fit compare to other mainstream brands such as Vasque, Salomon, Merrell, etc??


5 years ago
Jim51111

David - For a number of seasons I used a pair of Vasque that had a similar design. I found that the Arc'teryx molded to my foot better and felt more comfortable overall.


5 years ago

Like the engineering ideas, flaws in liner design.

Rating: rated 0.5 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $190

Summary

Like the engineering ideas, flaws in liner design.

Pros

  • Great concept
  • Comfortable
  • Lightweight
  • Breathable

Cons

  • Liner rubbed both my heels bloody within 3 miles

As a big fan of Arc'teryx products I was excited to see how they would reinvent the approach shoe. I liked the weight, the seamless body, the airflow, they were very comfortable. BUT, the first short hike of about three miles with no-show socks revealed that the non removable liner keeps moving around in the heel area, cutting through the skin of both my heels until blistering and bleeding.

Can't return since they have been worn and the blistering is (according to Arc'teryx rep) not a reason to send them back for a refund. I never had an issue with any shoe before. My feet are not overly sensitive. In my opinion these shoes are problematic if worn without protective socks between the liner and the skin.

There is a good reason that most manufacturers put a lot of thought into a non-abrasive heel design.

In my case a complete letdown.

Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Welcome to Trailspace, Pascal. Thanks for sharing your review of the Acrux. Too bad they didn't work out for you and you couldn't return them.


5 years ago

Where to Buy

Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.