Reviews

The Tredagain Claystone offers quality construction,…

Rating: rated 5 of 5 stars
Source: tested or reviewed it for the manufacturer (I received a discount code for this product from the brand or its representatives in exchange for a review.)

Summary

The Tredagain Claystone offers quality construction, sturdy to the touch, thick but supple leather, and a comfortable, cradling fit!

Pros

  • Environmentally sensitive
  • "Leave a better footprint" company
  • True to size
  • Out of the box all day comfort
  • Stylish
  • Great customer service
  • Recycled, upcycled

Cons

  • Strong leather treatment odor (new baseball mitt smell)
  • Foot lugs not fully self-cleaning

36A77EFE-66CB-4112-82B8-7D376B926B08.jpg

As I open the box and remove the Tredagain Claystone boots, the leather upper gives a combination of an aged, distressed appearance. Tredagain describes it as a full-grain waxed upper.

I find the classic moccasin toe of the Claystone model attractive and stylish. Tredagain branded the Claystone an Oxford, but I would describe it more as a "chukka" boot.
64636B47-E0C9-4D65-B414-E5700AA28902.jpgAs the member of another website, periodically, I'll have opportunity to review outdoor products at discounted or no cost. I was given the opportunity to review the Tredagain Claystone Oxford both with a discount code and I found them on sale over the holidays. Bonus! List price is $120

The "tricot" style liner mimics a suede-like appearance visually and to the touch. The shoelaces give the appearance of leather the same coloring of the boot leather. No clue if this was a forethought by the manufacturer, but a nice touch. I did find that it was necessary to double knot said shoelaces or they came untied due to their slickness.

71E4DD15-31A9-4E47-A823-04988E8A9D27.jpg

Boot upper stitiching appears uniform and stylish in accents. The bonding of the APX rubber sole to the leather upper is well done, leaving no trace of glue marks on or puckers in the leather. As you read about Tredagain you learn every outsole contains 50% upcycled rubber compound called APX.

All upcycled soles are produced here in the US of A! Diverting roughly 3,000 tires yearly from landfills and converting them into clean rubber compounds. How's that for sustainability? Their company mantra: "Leave A Better Footprint." Gotta love that! Tredagain is based in Austin, Texas.

587ECA23-BD0C-45BC-890C-CBB2283D7A9E.jpg

The sole appears rugged and durable, yet is quite flexible. Nothing is noted on the Tredagain website about the Claystone possessing a shank of any type for added support or protection and I was able to feel rocks, branches and such pressing up into the bottom of the footbed while hiking. I also noticed the tight tread lines picked up and retained tiny pebbles, shell, etc from the trails I hiked, so I would not describe the sole as self-cleaning.

Casual wear created no such problem. Remarkably, much thought went into the removable antomical footbed. It is well-cushioned, comfortable, and thicker than what most companies provide.

59EDDA96-8270-4B91-B89B-D060E214A329.jpgWearability: I found the Tredagain Claystone Oxford model true to size, just as the company representative advised when I inquired. I wear a 9.5 in almost all my shoes/boots…and the Claystone Oxford's in 9.5 fit nicely. If comfort is king…the Tredagain Claystone Oxford's reign!

Although, I'll keep that in an urban or casual hiking setting. These are not technical boots. I would not recommend them for backpacking or treking on rock strewn trails as they lack the torsional or vertical support my feet need in footwear. I do see myself wearing the Claystone Oxfords often for everyday use. It should be noted that Tredagain does not advertise the Claystone Oxford as a hiking or backpacking boot.

Be forewarned: The shoes possess a very strong leather treatment odor initially. Think new baseball mitt smell. Personally, I like the smell, but other household members and vehicle passengers may find it overpowering.

8FB6052F-C8DE-447E-BF06-21486C1DEFC0.jpg

Parting shots: I like the boots..a lot, and I look forward to their longevity. But what sets this company apart from (and ahead of) many other companies is their customer service. What attracts and keeps me loyal to product brands, is both dependable, durable goods and excellent customer service.

When I called Tredagain with a question, a real live young lady answered the phone. She entertained and answered my questions, gave me her name and advised to call and ask for her personally, if there was ever a problem. To me…that's huge!

Tredagain Claystone Oxford boots receive 5 stars from me!

Disclosure: The reviewer received a sample of this product from the brand or its representatives in exchange for a review.

G00SE

Sound like some nice boots. Thanks for the review.


1 year ago
Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Thanks for the review, CY. They are good looking shoes. How many miles do you think you have on your pair so far?


1 year ago

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.