Open main menu

Write a Review

The Mountaineers Books The Outdoor Knots Book

Camping/Hiking/Backpacking Book
review a different product


Overall, how do you rate this product?


Summary: In two to four sentences, sum up the most important things you want others to know about this product, based on your experience.

What is this product best for?

Would you recommend it or not? If so, for whom? For what use?



Pros: What are the product's strengths, its best features and qualities?

Acknowledge the positive. Even a disappointing product probably has something good going for it.

Please list one per line.

Cons: What are the product's weaknesses and limitations?

Acknowledge the negative. Even your favorite product probably has some drawbacks.

Please list one per line.

Detailed Review

What to write?

Here are some things to consider when reviewing a book or map:

  • Content: What does it cover? What info is included? Are there maps, illustrations, or images?
  • Structure: How is the info laid out and presented? Is it easy to find? Does it make sense?
  • Genre: How does this book or map compare to others in its category? No book can cover everything on a subject or place, but does this one offer unique and useful info?
  • Audience: For whom is this book written? For what range of experience levels?
  • Author: Who wrote this book? What is their background and expertise in the subject? How well do they present the info and in what style?
  • Usefulness: How would you use this book or map? At home for planning? On a trip? Would you pair it with another book or map?
  • Recommendation: Sum up your feelings and recommendation about the book. How did you use it? Was it helpful? Would you recommend it, and if so to whom?

Make it a Killer Review

Use video A brief video can clarify points further. Use video judiciously and consider how it can enhance your review: show ease of setup or product details, give a demonstration. More tips for a killer review »

Product Source: where'd you get it?

How did you acquire this product?

How much did you pay? ?

Please tell us more:

Product Source: If a company provided the product you're reviewing or if you have any personal or professional connection to it, say so in your review.

Be a trustworthy reviewer. Bolster your reputation with honesty and transparency.


Experience: In two to four sentences, sum up your level of experience with this product.

Familiarity with this product: How long have you owned it? How much have you used it? Number of trips? Miles?

Familiarity with product type: What's your experience with other models of this type of gear? Is this your first, one of many?

Conditions: Where and how have you used this product? In what conditions, terrain, and weather? When? For what activities?

new user
returning member

Join Now

Already a member? Sign in »
Full Name: shown on your review
Email: not shown
Create a Password:

When you post a review on Trailspace you agree to abide by the Gear Review Rules and Guidelines and Terms of Service.