Reviews

If a bear can is required or deemed necessary, this…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Source: received it as a personal gift

Summary

If a bear can is required or deemed necessary, this is a good choice.

Pros

  • Good shape to put on pack
  • See-through
  • Easy to find food
  • Straight sides stow food better than curved
  • Makes a good seat

Cons

  • Lid can get slippery
  • Hard to get a grip on canister
  • Can be Fiddly to open

While this can is harder to open than some of its counterparts, the benefits outweigh the one con. And with some practice, opening it becomes less of a hassle. I've tried a couple different techniques that take some of the frustration out of the process.

Because this can is straight sided, food packs very neatly and compactly inside. I managed to stow nine days' worth of food in my canister as well as my hiking partner's. The neck and lid accommodate that last little "cram" space.

Another asset is the clear plastic construction. I didn't have to unpack the can every time I wanted to find something.

The feature that is the nicest benefit is the flat topped lid. I used carpet tape and a cut down kneeling pad, and I always have a camp chair.

I have had this can for three summers, and have carried it for several different trips over dozens of miles. I have carried this on quick little overnighters to multiday PCT trips to my daughter using it to summit Mount Adams. I love not having to hang a bear line, and it's nice to know the little varmints will stay out of my food, too.

While the can defeats the ultra-light approach I like to take, it's a great solution to food storage and protection. I have found the can to be little worse for wear after being used, dropped, and kicked.

Heck, I've dumped out the food and hauled water when getting water was inconvenient!

I would get this can all over again.

Better to have it and not need it. I needed it. Love…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars
Source: bought it new
Price Paid: $76.95 shipped from Backcountry.com

Summary

Better to have it and not need it. I needed it.

Pros

  • Fits horizontal in my Bora 65; bearly LOL!
  • Human food for humans
  • It will work until them bars learn to twist lock
  • I only hike west of the Great Divide
  • Can be used for more than food
  • At 2lbs/9ozs lighter and larger than Garcia, UDAP, and Lighter 1
  • I can see what's inside to reach it easily
  • Cheaper than a LocTote Flak Sack II
  • Great camp stool, too

Cons

  • One bear on the AT named Yellow Yellow already has learned how
  • She's teaching others her technique
  • It always takes up a lot of space in the pack
  • Heavier than a Ursack 7.6ozs or LocTote Flak Sack II 2lbs
  • Doesn't change dimensions like Ursack Major or Flak Sack II

Love to walk our Redwood National and State Parks here in the 'hood. Love those black bears and their scat's on the trail. Of course, the blackberries are ripe. Keep 'em wild.

That's right, you can read about Yellow Yellow on the AT opening these by twisting her head and shearing the lock tabs. It's the hundredth monkey effect, but it's black bears around her slowly picking up the technique. My treks are all West of the Great Divide, so no worries for now.

https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/25/nyregion/25bear.html

Of course, no packable food container is bear-proof, only resistant; meaning it passed the IGBC test for certification. I bought the BV500 over other canisters predominately because it's clear and affordable for me. I want to see what's in it. Its size makes it good for a camp stool, too. When packing less food there's room for other gear, so the space isn't wasted. Unlike the xt and LocTote Flak Sack II, if a bear does get a hold of the BV500, the contents will probably remain intact and my trek will still be on.

If I had my druthers, I druther a got the only IGBC CERTIFIED backpack; the LocTote Flak Sack II 13L that cost $150, but the BV500 at $77 will do fine until I do.

P.S. For odor-free bagging forget about the overpriced ones and just do what the pot growers do here in Humboldt; use turkey bags. They're tough, odor-free and much cheaper.

BigRed

Here's a more up to date telling of the legend of Yellow Yellow: https://rootsrated.com/stories/the-legend-of-yellow-yellow-new-york-s-most-infamous-bear . She was legally shot by a hunter in 2012. It seems that no other bears, at least in the Adirondacks, have learned to open the lids on BV canisters, but according to the article some can get their teeth in them well enough to run off with them so they can go work on them in private. I just read through an Andrew Skurka article on bears and food in Yosemite reporting on 199 incidents. He does mention bears chewing into canisters but rather human errors of one kind or another allowing bears access to food in canisters in ursacks. So BVs are probably just fine when closed properly.


7 months ago
JRinGeorgia

Yeah, Yellow Yellow is long dead, and was in the Adirondacks not on the AT. I also don't think she learned to defeat the revised BV bear canisters that use two tabs instead of one.


7 months ago
Mike Mineart

I have a BV500 and it has always worked well , but this year I picked up a BV450 as I have found that most of my trip are not longer then six days and I can get five days in the BV450 and have the first days food in my pack. Its always nice to save some a little weight and space when you can...


6 months ago

All bear canisters are heavy and bulky, but this one…

Rating: rated 4.5 of 5 stars
Source: bought via a "pro deal"
Price Paid: $50

Summary

All bear canisters are heavy and bulky, but this one makes up for some that by being transparent, secure, versatile, and fairly priced. If you're in a place that requires a canister then this is an excellent choice.

Pros

  • Transparent
  • Tough
  • Designed to be carried inside or outside pack
  • Secure
  • Doubles as a seat

Cons

  • Heavy
  • Bulky
  • Lid can be a challenge to open

I've had my Bearvault BV500 for many years now and have used it several times in the high Sierra of California. It's my guess that no one wants to carry a bear canister due to their bulkiness and weight, but the BV500 has some features that make is a good choice when you have no choice other than to carry a canister.

Despite the years of use the device is still in excellent condition and works like new. It weighs 2 pounds 9 ounces. There is a smaller version for shorter trips that weighs 2 pounds 1 ounce.

First off, being transparent is a real plus. Instead of digging around in a dark hole searching for a bag of gorp or a tube of toothpaste you can see where things from the outside and then just reach in and grab it. For me this is a major plus over other brands of canisters.  

Additionally, the outside of the canister is grooved and has some raised bumps that allow it to be securely strapped to the outside of a pack if preferred. A smooth surface, like most other canisters, pretty much guarantees that the canister will fall off the pack at the most inconvenient moment.  

With careful planning I can fairly easily carry a week (six nights) of food and toiletries in my canister. There are a few tricks. 1)  Make use of all space. Plan and pack carefully.  2)  Crackers or any breakable items will likely be crushed in a packed canister.  3) Use tortillas instead. 4)  Keep in mind that your trash will have to be stored in the canister at nights. 5) Chocolate will melt when a canister is left in the sun.

What are the downsides? It can be difficult to open. In order to open it you have to press in on the rim of the lid to cause a small tabs on the lid to pass over similar tabs on the canister body. Small hands may have a problem with this, but it's easy to use a spoon handle, stick, or whatever to depress the lid in order to open it.

One caution is to not get dirt or grit into the threads on the lid or canister. Grit can cause it to be very difficult to remove the lid. Rinse clean and then dry if you get the lid dirty.

When the lid is screwed all the way on the canister makes a nice seat.  A canister will fit vertically or horizontally inside a larger backpack. Mine fits in my 70L and 85L packs with no problems. I carried it outside of a pack once and that worked fine, but I find it easier to use my larger pack and carry the canister inside.

The canister has been repeatedly tested to stand up to black bears and grizzly bears. In the Sierras, for the most part, bears just walk away from canisters since they know that they can't open them. 

Alicia MacLeay TRAILSPACE STAFF

Thanks for sharing your helpful bear canister review, Mentalfloss1.


5 years ago

I used this bear canister in late August in Rocky…

Rating: rated 4 of 5 stars

I used this bear canister in late August in Rocky Mountain National Park, CO. It was a rental as I typically prefer bear bags over canisters, but bags were not permitted in said park (apparently mother bears have taken to sending their cubs up trees after bags).

This canister was light enough and with some clever arrangement in my pack, I had no problems with its bulk, either. I can't comment on this canister's resilience to bear attacks as I did not encounter one while on the trip, but it was hard enough for ME to open up. I can only imagine that a bear would find it impossible without thumbs.

Bottom line: This is a pretty solid canister; I gave it 4 stars simply because I greatly prefer to use bags, so take this review with a grain of salt.

Where to Buy

sponsored links
Help support this site by making your next gear purchase through one of the links above. Click a link, buy what you need, and the seller will contribute a portion of the purchase price to support Trailspace's independent gear reviews.